Highest Rated Episodes in MAL

Jun 25, 2020 5:50 PM

Offline

Jul 2019

810

Really unfortunate stuff man, I honestly wonder why people do that. I'd go for option 2 ideally but I don't have much ideas to ensure it works well so I think option 3 is probably what you'll have to do (well, if you want to). I don't care much about the ratings of episodes, I actually haven't gone on an episode discussion after watching "x" episode of "x" show ever so honestly those score manipulations don't matter at all to me. You had the firsthand data and then it was downvoted. Just keep with what you have. Anyways I don't think you'd have updated all episodes everytime you add some new ones (or maybe I'm wrong), so keeping on updating it like normally would be fine despite having scores displayed be at different times. Again, ideally all the 90+ scores would be revealed at once to stop this problem but things seem to not always go as planned...

My Fav OPs & EDs

Redline Review

Jun 25, 2020 9:33 PM

#102

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

BiDiGiN said:
Really unfortunate stuff man, I honestly wonder why people do that. I'd go for option 2 ideally but I don't have much ideas to ensure it works well so I think option 3 is probably what you'll have to do (well, if you want to). I don't care much about the ratings of episodes, I actually haven't gone on an episode discussion after watching "x" episode of "x" show ever so honestly those score manipulations don't matter at all to me. You had the firsthand data and then it was downvoted. Just keep with what you have. Anyways I don't think you'd have updated all episodes everytime you add some new ones (or maybe I'm wrong), so keeping on updating it like normally would be fine despite having scores displayed be at different times. Again, ideally all the 90+ scores would be revealed at once to stop this problem but things seem to not always go as planned...

People do that because, as some serial killer said, they can.
That must have sounded cringe af. xD

First, I forgot to mention it again, AAHHH! but there's actually a 4th option, well, kind of: to temporarily stop the updating of the list, and update it once and for all when the list is complete, for that case I would't need to re-release the list, so it could help with the downvoting, though I also was considering do it with the list up but just adding all the episodes premiered from here on that meet the requirements, to keep some actuality in the list (but that would bug the accuracy date). Doing this, it would be a more fair list, but it would last some few hours, because as fast as I do that update, I'm sure we'll be seing some titles being downvoted to hell (ok, not that badly) like we have seen, so after that it would lost that value; at the end, it doesn't solves the problem, it just delays it.

Second, I think I got right what you mean, so yeah, when one single episode meets the requirements it's added to the list without updating the whole thing, the only exception to it are recently premiered episode, to not bug the accuracy date, those instead are added with the weekly update next to its premiere; the 4th option would be similar, just that weekly updates would stop till the list gets completed. If I get right what you mean with updating it normally and keeping with what I have, yeah, that actually might help to reduce the problem, as any title outside the list would be kept safe, but, and I'm gonna sound like your average source material reader with every adaptation, things get really interesting from here on, so I really wanna continue with it as long as this is guaranteed to not be a major problem.

Last but not least, thank you for taking the time to response, it's actually helpful to see how others perceive this.

Nov 7, 2023 2:07 PM

#103

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

Hello there once again

Gotta be honest, I've always wondered if continuing this or not, and after giving it some thoughts, I decided to try it again.
Things have changed a lot, one pandemic included, from anime going fully mainstream to some new features in MAL, this list might be at its most meaningful moment while at the same time its more meaningless... it's weird. Just to better show the point, remember when Kimetsu no Yaiba 19 was the most voted episode ever? Now its 9k votes, while impressive, are not such a big thing, and with a wider audience it's far harder to make everyone join your hypetrain and maintain its momentum, reflected in many statistics, these episodes ratings among them (a little example); to say it clearly and short, nowadays it's not a common thing a rating as high a 90%, even those which have broken the internet have it hard to keep such universal level of approval, it's way uniquer to see that.
Yeah, main reason for this was to show off Frieren
Also, with rating wars being worse than ever, migrating to other sites even, and seeing what had happened before (feel free to read the whole thread, it's quite a show), this might be not so much of a good idea, but I just wanted to give it another shot.

Hope you enjoy

mafd12Nov 16, 2023 10:50 PM

Nov 16, 2023 10:50 PM

#104

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

If any of you remember, the rule for a new episode was that if it met the requirements I'd wait a day to add it to the list, with weekly updates on mind; now I think a week is a good time for ratings to settle and add the episode, with monthly updates being the new tentative if I continue with this list for real.
With that said, Sousou no Frieren Episode 10 added.

mafd12Nov 17, 2023 8:11 AM

Nov 17, 2023 3:08 AM

#105

Cestlavie_

Offline

Jul 2021

911

Reply to mafd12

If any of you remember, the rule for a new episode was that if it met the requirements I'd wait a day to add it to the list, with weekly updates on mind; now I think a week is a good time for ratings to settle and add the episode, with monthly updates being the new tentative if I continue with this list for real.
With that said, Sousou no Frieren Episode 10 added.

@mafd12
Please do you mind writing the titles in English as well

Nov 17, 2023 4:02 AM

#106

Pinoffin

Offline

Nov 2023

1431

Clannad:After story is a masterpiece, l loved seeing it on top.

Hush! My dear, don't you cry
Pino gonna sing you a lullaby
Hush! My dear, don't be sad
Pino gonna sing a song he heard.

Nov 17, 2023 3:57 PM

#107

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

Reply to Cestlavie_

@mafd12
Please do you mind writing the titles in English as well

@Cestlavie
For consistency's sake, I'll keep the titles of the series the same as they are on MAL

Nov 17, 2023 4:10 PM

#108

KitsuFrost

Offline

Aug 2020

7742

Yorimoi is such a behemoth for being there amongst long running shows lol

Dec 9, 2023 3:50 AM

#109

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

New update!

I decided to lower the cut line already, though just a little, to 900 votes. I also remarked the 90% as the minimum for entering the list, as I mentioned in a prior post, nowadays is pretty rare to witness these numbers despite the impact these episodes might've had in the community, so I was thinking that lowering the percentage might be fair... 89? 88? I'unno, what do you think?
I also started taking snapshots at the Web Archive, it might be a good countermeasure to downvoting.
Anyways, hope you enjoy.

mafd12Jan 23, 12:36 PM

Dec 30, 2023 6:37 PM

#110

Rob7

Offline

May 2019

3291

mafd12 said:
Highest Rated Episodes in MAL
Current Cut Line: 900 votes - 90%

Clannad: After Story - Episode 18 -> 95.6% - 3389 votes
Gintama° - Episode 40 -> 95.5% - 1063 votes
Hunter x Hunter (2011) - Episode 135 -> 95.3% - 3814 votes
Sora yori mo Tooi Basho - Episode 12 -> 95.2% - 1697 votes
Shingeki no Kyojin Season 3 Part 2 - Episode 5 -> 94.6% - 5550 votes
(...)

This list is pure gold, thanks for updating it!

Even better than the general MAL ranking to point superb anime.

And 90% 5/5 is ok for a selection of really excepcional episodes.

Rob7Dec 30, 2023 6:41 PM

Dec 31, 2023 6:19 AM

#111

Akaseaka

Offline

Dec 2023

1

Thank you for making this list. I'm so surprised that a list like this is still updating after three and a half years! Happy new year btw!

Since the list is sorted by percentage, lowering the percentage to 89% or 88% will just make the list longer. I've read the whole thread, but I'm don't exactly understand what the problem is. However, I think you could add a separater at 90% or whatever level you deem fit, leave a note there to make your message clear: "Some episodes below may not be as good" or something like that.

To be honest, I am not really bothered about current level of score manipulation. Half of the anime on the list are not my genre and I don't even like them. However, I'm surprised to see that some of the anime I like are on the list, and it makes me want to rewatch some of them, and I think it's great! Thank you again for making this list.

Jan 23, 12:26 PM

#112

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

New update!
Cut line has been lowered again, now it's at 750 votes; a good bunch of new titles got into. Also, for now I'll keep it at 90% and see how it goes, but I'm starting to lean onto lowering it a bit.

Happy new year btw! Almost february already but still

Jan 23, 1:14 PM

#113

Acctra

Offline

Jan 2021

1024

Very rarely do I remember (or vote) for specific episodes, but episode 12 of Bakemonogatari was really special.

Jan 23, 2:06 PM

#114

epidemia78

Offline

Aug 2018

8181

After Story #18 absolutely deserves the top ranking. Faith in humanity restored.

Jan 23, 2:11 PM

#115

DoctorWasabi

Offline

Jan 2014

3678

One Piece 1015 was fucking stellar dude, it got me so emotional.

Also it baffles me that One Piece 1062 is not in the top 10, shit not even on the list even

It was the KING OF HELL episode, and was easily top 3 greatest episodes ever made in anime history

Jan 23, 2:41 PM

#116

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

Reply to DoctorWasabi

One Piece 1015 was fucking stellar dude, it got me so emotional.

Also it baffles me that One Piece 1062 is not in the top 10, shit not even on the list even

It was the KING OF HELL episode, and was easily top 3 greatest episodes ever made in anime history

@DoctorWasabi Yeah, a victim of downvoting as well

Jan 23, 3:37 PM

#117

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

3618

Reply to mafd12

New update!
Cut line has been lowered again, now it's at 750 votes; a good bunch of new titles got into. Also, for now I'll keep it at 90% and see how it goes, but I'm starting to lean onto lowering it a bit.

Happy new year btw! Almost february already but still

@mafd12 I think the threshold of 90% "loved it" is ideal, but the threshold of 750 votes seems kind of random. I understand that it shouldn't be too low, otherwise obscure stuff could enter the list, but on the other hand there are many older episodes from early MAL times when much less users rated the episodes. For example One Piece Episode 309 is one of the most famous and liked episodes of the entire franchise, but even with 90.9% it doesn't make it into your list because it currently has less than 400 votes due to the aforementioned reason.
Another slightly odd thing is that your list currently is a top 71 list, instead of top 100.
Do you know how many new episodes would enter your list if you lowered the vote-threshold to 250 ?
If that's not enough to turn it into a top 100 list, then how low would it have to be in order to include the missing 29 episodes?

This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.

Jan 29, 7:42 PM

#118

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

Reply to Zarutaku

@mafd12 I think the threshold of 90% "loved it" is ideal, but the threshold of 750 votes seems kind of random. I understand that it shouldn't be too low, otherwise obscure stuff could enter the list, but on the other hand there are many older episodes from early MAL times when much less users rated the episodes. For example One Piece Episode 309 is one of the most famous and liked episodes of the entire franchise, but even with 90.9% it doesn't make it into your list because it currently has less than 400 votes due to the aforementioned reason.
Another slightly odd thing is that your list currently is a top 71 list, instead of top 100.
Do you know how many new episodes would enter your list if you lowered the vote-threshold to 250 ?
If that's not enough to turn it into a top 100 list, then how low would it have to be in order to include the missing 29 episodes?

@Zarutaku I actually hadn't considered a top, I was just listing the episodes that met the criteria, but after you mentioned it I made the exercise, though I decided to include only 1000+ votes episodes, to make it easier (it wasn't).

Also, doing the research I remember that I had a screenshot of the list before the renewal, where you can see what I talked about, the fewer votes and the more broad sample of titles as it was more common for a series to get good episodes ratings before.

Jan 29, 8:20 PM

#119

Pinoffin

Offline

Nov 2023

1431

Reply to DoctorWasabi

One Piece 1015 was fucking stellar dude, it got me so emotional.

Also it baffles me that One Piece 1062 is not in the top 10, shit not even on the list even

It was the KING OF HELL episode, and was easily top 3 greatest episodes ever made in anime history

@DoctorWasabi As a One Piece Fan I'm agreed.

Hush! My dear, don't you cry
Pino gonna sing you a lullaby
Hush! My dear, don't be sad
Pino gonna sing a song he heard.

Jan 30, 3:39 AM

#120

khoisharky

Offline

Jul 2022

187

Interesting, although I suggest lowering the vote cut line back to 500-600, leaving it at 750 leaves a lot of underrated titles unknown since most MAL users don't comment on episodes anyways.

Jan 30, 3:40 AM

#121

Pinoffin

Offline

Nov 2023

1431

I Really love the Clannad after story .

Hush! My dear, don't you cry
Pino gonna sing you a lullaby
Hush! My dear, don't be sad
Pino gonna sing a song he heard.

Jan 30, 4:54 AM

#122

gh0ul69

Offline

Aug 2021

50

Very surprised End of the Prologue (Vinland Saga, ep 24) isn't on here considering its 9.9 imdb rating.

Jan 30, 5:47 AM

#123

-Sleek-

Offline

Aug 2023

320

Sora yori mo Tooi Basho Episode 12 is the best episode i have watched in all anime. That episode was beyond amazing.

Feb 17, 1:30 AM

#124

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

New update once again.
Cut line lowered to 600 votes, a good number of new titles got into but, as some might have expected, the dominance by Gintama and One Piece starts to show off. Also, BokuYabai S2 episode 6 added.

Feb 17, 2:27 AM

#125

khoisharky

Offline

Jul 2022

187

Nice, now some underrated stuff are showing up.

Feb 23, 11:41 PM

#126

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

The list now has over 100 titles, so I decided to add recently aired episodes straigth onto the list after a week without updating the whole list (I updated it for Frieren's 10th iirc), despite messing a little with the accuracy date. Therefore, BokuYabai S2 episode 7 added.

Feb 23, 11:46 PM

#127

Serafos

Offline

Feb 2020

75138

Nice to see K-On!!, Sora yori mo Tooi Basho, and Haikyuu!! on the list.

Mar 9, 5:47 PM

#128

Rob7

Offline

May 2019

3291

I don't think it will last more than a few days in the top 100, but right now the best episode of Sousou no Frieren made to the list: 91,7% 5/5

https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2149633&show=0

Mar 15, 7:09 AM

#129

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

Reply to Rob7

I don't think it will last more than a few days in the top 100, but right now the best episode of Sousou no Frieren made to the list: 91,7% 5/5

https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2149633&show=0

Yeah, as stated before, a week of wait to let it settle a bit, so now it's added.

Mar 22, 7:16 AM

#130

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

Well, new update.
Tentatively, next month the cut line will down to 500 votes, which could be the definitive. I'll be thinking about it.

Apr 6, 10:50 AM

#131

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

It's been a week, so BokuYabai S2 episode 13 now added.

Apr 6, 11:02 AM

#132

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

3618

How do you find all these episodes that fulfill the requirements and how can you be sure that you didn't miss any?

This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.

Apr 6, 11:19 AM

#133

APolygons2

Offline

Oct 2019

6100

Id Invaded ep 10 being there is extremely surprising to me despite believing it deserves it.

Maybe some corners of this website have good taste after all.

Also available at:
YouTube Channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCK8spdL1M_J-z0vO2C7jPLw
Second Channel: https://www.youtube.com/@AshPolygonsDo/videos
Why You Should Watch Akudama Drive: https://youtu.be/Yw0r52wRjgA
A Love Letter To Anime「AMV」: https://youtu.be/YQyqxFM2m9Q

My referral code to a website/app that gives you free money (a few cents a day) by using a few megabytes of your internet for file sharing. We both get a bonus if you use my link: https://r.honeygain.me/ARSHIA7942

Apr 9, 1:30 PM

#134

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

Reply to Zarutaku

How do you find all these episodes that fulfill the requirements and how can you be sure that you didn't miss any?

@Zarutaku Short answer: I'm not fully sure. Someone said they knew a perfect episode rating, up to this day I'unno which one he's talking about
But as I mentioned before, there were some other lists which helped me at the start, @Damuzen the most helpful without a shred of doubt, and with that base I made a first list, with all the episodes qualified that I found at the time (in middle of the pandemic, with all the time of the world, naturally), and I've been adding upon that list episodes from new series or that have gotten an increase on either score or number of votes to enter the list. And it's been like that all this time.

Apr 9, 1:52 PM

#135

OiGon

Offline

Jan 2016

55

The fact that there is not a single fullmetal alchemist episode on this list tells something.

Apr 14, 1:03 AM

#136

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

One Piece 1100 added.

OiGon said:
The fact that there is not a single fullmetal alchemist episode on this list tells something.

Downvoted as well. With all the score wars FMA:B has been involved it's just natural, I guess, but still this shows the ugly side of MAL rankings.

Apr 14, 1:12 AM

#137

18927

Offline

Apr 2024

68

Reply to OiGon

The fact that there is not a single fullmetal alchemist episode on this list tells something.

@OiGon Toxic people and bots just don't rate on this site in justly manner.

Apr 15, 4:03 AM

#138

Trezeguett

Offline

Dec 2014

37

add this

https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=2153084

Apr 15, 4:25 AM

#139

NubFix

Offline

Jan 2019

851

this is really interesting, I always wanted to find this exact list for a long time, thanks!
not surprised Clannad After Story got the top spot tho

Apr 28, 10:05 PM

#140

Rob7

Offline

May 2019

3291

sorry for the bring it since is far from the top, but it happened right now and could not stop laughing. Also, remembered of this thread.

Apr 30, 8:18 PM

#141

Bruh69XD

Offline

Nov 2020

168

The top is where it belongs 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

May 8, 3:26 PM

#142

mafd12

Offline

Feb 2019

310

New update.
With a lower cut line we see some new titles, and more Gintama and One Piece as well. I was wondering about either leaving it here at 500, a pretty round number, or lower it a bit more, which would give space to more obscure titles to get in, though that might just be a question of time too.
I'unno.

May 9, 1:21 AM

#143

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

3618

Ohh new update, I really like this topic!

Aria the Origination now leading the field seems well deserved to me, I saw it many years ago and still vividly recall the feeling of episode 9.

mafd12 said:
I was wondering about either leaving it here at 500, a pretty round number, or lower it a bit more

I tend to agree, 500 seems solid, maybe 400 but not any lower. Hopefully One Piece episode 309 will make it into the ranking some day.

This dance is the pinnacle of human achievement.

» What device(s) do you watch anime content on? ( 1 2 ) DesuMaiden - May 18	85	by TheEyceOfSpades »» 2 minutes ago
» Write your takes in anime and I'll prove you're incorrect. Gashadokur0 - 2 hours ago	24	by Gashadokur0 »» 12 minutes ago
» "This was a Masterpiece!!!" sections or moments in shows that aren't that. APolygons2 - Apr 27	41	by APolygons2 »» 18 minutes ago
» Courage the Cowardly Dog Anime ZakuF_ - 3 hours ago	15	by pk8list »» 19 minutes ago
» Lifespan of an Anime fan? ( 1 2 ) Ex-Aid - 11 hours ago	63	by PeripheralVision »» 20 minutes ago

Highest Rated Episodes in MAL

More topics from this board

» What device(s) do you watch anime content on? ( 1 2 )

» Write your takes in anime and I'll prove you're incorrect.

» "This was a Masterpiece!!!" sections or moments in shows that aren't that.

» Courage the Cowardly Dog Anime

» Lifespan of an Anime fan? ( 1 2 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters