- Last OnlineJun 8, 12:57 AM
- JoinedJan 31, 2021
No friend yet.
RSS Feeds
|
Jun 5, 2024
Oh yeah this one is for me, supremely weird, funny and memey, the jokes sometimes fall flat and that is a form of cinema in itself. I am sad that this didn't get to flourish beyond what we got, I love a lil anti-conglomerate narrative, fuck them trying to monopolize the space and replacing fun with whatever their grubby lil greedy minds think. I love lil eggplant main character and his homies coming together to help a small business thrive. And yet in what little amount of chapters it had left in the build up, it still carried on with a cheery energy to carry
...
into its axing. I love it, I would rate it higher if it was allowed to grow.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jun 5, 2024
I feel like I will remember those that were cut short more than the ongoing series. Really beautiful art reminiscent of Witch Hat Atelier, which is one of my favorites, so I was drawn in by that at first. I will say, it's slow, not much happens throughout the narrative in comparison to the action-packed electric plots of everything else surrounding it, but I feel I wanted to give this a chance. Will I read Shun Akagi's work again? Yes. Am I running to go seek it out? No, I'll be slow with it. A solid start with an interesting universe, witches and humans are
...
able to have close contact with each other and trade in a rather bureaucratic way. Gadgets and scenery were similar to steampunk without the edge, closer to a Ghibli version of the world like A Howl's Moving Castle type of world. There's a mysterious magical energy running around and causing havoc, that's how many characters are brought together and an everlooming villain plagues the world. We finally get to figure out who it is, the connection between all characters, and then we get to see the backstory and why this all matters to our previously listless main witch character Nat. There's a beautiful seed of a story, one that shows how the overarching rules of the world might be wrong, something that might be explored with much more chapters in this authors runs. I don't know if they set out to do oneshots or given the situations that manga companies engage in, if it was axed. But given that we get to the climax and the ruling witch government just barely received their first case, I wonder what other moments/cases could mean for witch-human contact. I loved the apprentice-mentor relationship shared by Nat and I enjoyed this so much but feel that something like this deserves more time to cook, it is not something that entertains immediately, it contains very little hype, more so comfy and mysterious in familial connections, kind of like Frieren in that regard, we get to see things through the characters slowly. Given all this, I feel there's a cap on my enjoyment, I'm left sitting with the beauty of potential.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Jun 5, 2024
Yeah, fine is just how I'd describe it. You get what you ordered. Its art style is not at all within my wheelhouse, but it's fine, it's cute. I had no idea what to expect from this at all, the fact that there's a loosely held story is a plus. Asumi-chan wants to find a childhood crush but in the most convoluted of ways, like they're both just two ships in the night. And then a kouhai gets introduced and there sparks something akin to a relationship, some exploration. I'm happy to see the queer types of relationships happening here, and there is some good
...
moments of smut, I like the characters, but this ain't no masterpiece, just as the ranking system is saying: fine.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
May 15, 2024
I don't know if it's because my experience with fantasy anime is rather limited or if it's because I'm not seeking the high intensity anime bullshit that once enticed a younger me, but this to me is one of my favorite anime, maybe within the top 3. A better reviewer would deep dive into the individual aspects of how to arrive at that score, and to be honest I would give it an 8 objectively since some animation, designs, worldbuilding, and music is a tad less than perfect but my focus is not on any of those realms. Instead my great enjoyment of this anime
...
(and subsequent 10 score) stems from the story and the feeling of comfort I experienced as I watched it. When I read manga or read anime, the flashback to explain a powerup or important lesson or meaningful moment is a classic staple and Frieren had some of the best explorations of this trope, particularly why Frieren's favorite spell is how to create a field of flowers, it's a large connection to two of the most important people in her life in different moments across her timeline. Flashbacks are interspersed to give important background to various characters and seeing how it all interconnects in the end of the arc or episode is so satisfying. The travelling group encountering challenges on the daily and solving them in real time without quick need to advance is also fulfilling because sometimes you just gotta take things slow. At some point in the past I might have agreed with Fern's early reluctance to take things slow, as if the world was ending if I didn't get to the next step in the journey. But I think Frieren's stop and smell the roses approach is a tactic I'm learning to appreciate in my own life. Even though there is a large cast of characters coming in and out, the tender care the author/story provides in order to reveal their importance to the story is a good tactic in letting me enjoy the ride. The arcs we were given had a decent variety, sometimes solo growth arcs, sometimes flashback arcs, sometimes just chilling and getting through life arcs (Fern sick, Stark as prince) the tournament/exam arc of the end was a great pivot point to have people continue reading the manga onwards. The slow reveals in piecemeal tidbits of lore and the world I love, I've seen people say good or bad worldbuilding but I don't think there's an emphasis on the world because I agree it's underdeveloped but it's not something that would detract from the series since it's so character and storydriven. A deep world dive is not what we need to understand this land that Frieren inhabits, in fact, the majority of Frieren's existence has been her just living through things and not paying them any mind until she notices the finality of Himmel's death. I enjoyed watching a longlife being growing to understand the shortlived experience, to know and learn emotions of another species, to watch her and her friends just exist. It may reveal that I enjoy slice of life vibes, and to mix slice of life with fantasy, it was a treat.
Reviewer’s Rating: 10
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Mar 9, 2024
I dont know the history or what happened behind the scenes, all I know is that reception and sales matter more than any series that has an interesting potential. Often creations in this windmill of story after story of the manga industry might suffer to in never letting their wings expand. I think this story had a cool promise, the alien understanding human culture, the wild effects the alien forced people to be honest with themselves to a caricature extreme, the possible team up with a meh standard shonen woe-is-me protagonist who seems to get more resolve towards the end of this short story. The
...
gory and surprising bits of this are the main marketing for people, and they are effective, but towards the end, that post chapter 20 period, the story suffers from a need to wrap things up. It is rushed, it lacks any type of development, it's an epilogue tacked on to a preface and a couple pages-length book. I wanted more than the finished product and with 20 chapters, the story doesn't grow enough to leave a lasting impact beyond the blood and bits within. I enjoyed the scribbly and wild art, but it is just a big meh-fest. Glad I read it though as I think the artist has great potential.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 22, 2024
Undoubtedly(for me) the best manga running in all of shonen jump right now, it is great (9/10) because it is still running so it better not derail its train. This is such a refreshing and different take on battle manga, it being rakugo and rising through the ranks, it's fun and the art is just chef's kiss, the facial expressions are the definition of expressive. It's a slow burn in a field I know nothing about and it made me seek out some new form of entertainment. I might never be fully into rakugo but through Akane's experience, I know enough and for that I
...
am happy.
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 18, 2024
you know, the gimmick of the evil team versus the power ranger team, i think it's cute and i think it's silly, and it was a good short time. classic cliches of many a manga where there's a rival, non-communication, misunderstandings, couple being embarrassed at the smallest things, cliches of school life, but I'M GONNA SAY IT, I thought it was a fun read with an enjoyable gimmick. There were great wholesome moments and I wished we got more progression of beast princess and the guy on gelato 5 who was into her. I think it's a manga that doesn't overstay its welcome at its
...
almost 40 chapters, short and sweet with nice art and character designs but rather one note characters, which is fine for a, to borrow other reviewer's words, fast food experience of some lovebirds going through it. Just two fumbling dummies who are extremely strong and going about love for the first time.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 11, 2024
Some good, some bad. I know that Gengoroh Tagame is capable of making a compelling story and drawing in amazing and endearing simplicity, his eye to attention is in the characters.
I'm a little disappointed in the emphasis on the title, the protagonist's emphasis on color particularly in the descriptions of surroundings, of characters, of clothing...... and the lack of color present. Granted, I know that'll cost both the publisher and the consumer extra and even though I rented it from the library, I've seen manga engage in portraying some pages with color, it would add such beauty to the story. (HUGE SPOILER TO THE ENDING)
...
I understand stories have engaged in age gap exploration and I can see its merit but not when it's an underage kid in high school and an older person post-50s, I felt that it might venture there and I was hoping it wasn't but it did and the concerns of the ex-wife character and the mom came true, that the adult engaged in a poor decision. I've seen Gengoroh Tagame's work be better and do better, and unfortunately I'm simply a human who compares this work to My Brother's Husband and it's a tall ask.
The good: it's a simple story and a quick-ish read, while I see some reviewers have noted the lack of internet on behalf of the protagonist, there's something about him that is just kind of naive which makes sense, he's young and dumb figuring things out. I enjoyed watching the value of community form and I'm glad there wasn't some melodramatic back and forth about outing that you see in other teenage-misunderstanding stories. The characters felt realistic and grounded and quite simple. They apologized to each other for such mishaps and they promised to grow, I quite enjoyed that. I loved the support once the protagonist comes out. Was the plot the best? Not really, I think the author is so much more talented but just wasn't the most fulfilling plot for me, but part of me thinks, was the author writing to his current self or his past self with the ending in mind, it's a little rough to be fully okay with things. Wish the protag was a little older.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 11, 2024
So you're coming off of reading Starving Anonymous, then you think... "what? a sequel? okay let's get into it." For those who might have jumped from Kingdom Hearts 1 to Kingdom Hearts 2, there's a leap that you don't understand... something's off, who are these protagonists? What is this world? Why is everything seemingly peaceful in what was a wild ride of a previous installment?
There's something quite juicy about a world that is, to its readers, obviously wrong, but everyone within the narrative continues as if nothing is wrong. So then we peer through the lens of those who would be deemed as misfits, that's
...
what I value about these kinds of stories. The outcasts and the weird ones are those who can challenge the status quo. Of course, our protagonist pales in comparison to the weird kids he meets, and especially in comparison to the main group of the previous story, hell even the transformed friend in the first story is braver than this protagonist, but I found it quite realistic against the backdrop of wild powers in this sequel. The ending felt quite justified and brutally realistic because in a society that had one belief so strongly for years, then a new ideology is confronted, it's hard to abandon things fully.
In my review for Starving Anonymous, I noted the similarities to Gantz, this one story melds the last arc of Gantz and Starving Anonymous and takes a sharp look at idolatry of the gods/aliens. While I grade the prequel and the sequel the same, I edge this one over a little bit because we do get to see some references to the prequel. This is a wild ride I would recommend with similar art and a larger scale than before.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
Feb 11, 2024
I think it's a solid story of balls to the walls action and madness, I think the ending is quite tragic and sad, and I was honestly surprised that there would be a sequel, . I would definitely not recommend if you are uncomfortable with gore and guts, I read this after reading Gantz and while I found that 400ish chapter ride quite hellish and gory and edgy, this is below that level, not quite as intense in its visuals and storytelling but still a nice ride. At first, I was drawn in by this human mystery and then it turned into an alien farming
...
situation quite quickly. I love a good human versus overpowered alien story, no matter the ending.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|