- Supporter
- Last Online8 hours ago
- GenderMale
- BirthdayJun 21, 1997
- LocationCluj-Napoca, Romania
- JoinedDec 6, 2018
Fantasy Anime League You Should Read This Manga My MALentine Story Fantasy Anime League MALoween Mansion (Trapped Soul) Fantasy Anime League MAL Bunkasai Visitor Paradox Live Also Available at
RSS Feeds
|
![]()
Apr 17, 2022
So... I did not expect this, but I didn't like Sing a Bit of Harmony as much as I've wanted to. Even now, I consider Time of Eve to be a quintessential cosy Sci-Fi and one of the better examples of playing with AI-related ideas (even transhumanist ones to some extent) in the medium. Harmonie and Aquatic Language were also really nice. And I tend to overrate everything slightly musical in nature too. Everything was looking favourable at first. Heck, if I were to compile my 10 favourite movies in a top, more than half would be musicals. But the main difference between those and
...
our culprit is the fact that the formers couldn't be summed up by a reductionist as *drum roll, please*
'Platitudes: The Almost-Musical'
West Side Story was innovative, equally actual from a political POV today as it was back then, thought-provoking even, for it is not a simple LEFT good, RIGHT bad. La La Land's cinematography was on point, the songs were memorable and I still listen to them even now, almost 6 years later. And it had Emma Stone and Ryan Gosling in there. Moulin Rouge? I remember it being the first movie that made me feel really emotional and it's 10 times cheesier, dumber and less natural when it comes to human interactions. But I don't hate it either. It's cute, it's nice, it's an adventure about a singing robot-waifu making friends with your average group of high-schoolers. It's not a bad movie by any means. Actually all of them had great music, besides Sing a Bit of Harmony.
Having given those 3 examples, I feel like I have created some sort of pattern for what makes a good musical in my book. I feel like this movie fails in these aspects. The message, despite being quite morally-heavy, is not that interesting and neither is it thought-provoking, for it doesn't bring anything new regarding the topic. However, I'll be fair: It's a nice message and raising awareness about the corporate-AI relationship won't get old anytime soon. It might also be someone else's first contact with the idea and it might change his life completely. Who knows? So... Let's say this part is serviceable.
Next, the songs. I'm sorry, but this is nowhere near Belle even, which has aired recently. I have watched it twice already and I don't think there has been a single song that managed to escape the 'generic musical' mould you'd see in a middle school recital. I get it, it's supposed to be about high schoolers so it's fitting, but I genuinely don't care. Anthem of the Heart was in exactly the same spot, yet I really liked its songs, I found them memorable - here only the martial arts sequence one was quite close; actually that was one of the best scenes in this movie and it also had a nice transition thrown in there. It has plenty of energy, it is vibrant, it was a great hook for me, even 40 mins into the movie. But everything was sort of thrown away when we switched to the next scene. The voice acting is nice and the sound design is not lacking in any aspects, but if a musical fails to deliver on songs, I'm not gonna be the biggest fan. This is, by far, my biggest issue with this movie. I mean.. I'd even go as far as claiming that I like Annie get your gun more just because it had a really, REALLY good song, in spite of the ideological garbage that that movie is.
How about the cinematography? Don't get me wrong. It looks good overall, the animation is solid and there are some nice catches here and there, but they are few and far between. Dune was good because it was very orange. Zhang Yimou's movies are good because they are very red and so on (obviously kidding). But this movie was neither orange, nor red. Heck, Belle played a lot with the shots, it made great use of stills and close-ups, of long-shots, of everything. They were a part of the story. This one's most memorable cinematographic achievement was the fact that the videocalls were low quality and pixelated. Just like in real life. The future is grim. It doesn't matter if we have AI close to passing the Turing or the Coffee test, we will still have shitty internet connection and FHD-only videocalls. A point could also be made in favour of blue in some sequences, but when the scene switches, the emotion meant to be felt remains the same, yet you have a vividly-coloured, unfiltered shot, I don't think the point stands.
Lastly... emotion. In essence, the first half of the movie is a human drama involving a group of high-schoolers. Great. It's just like Hibike Euphonium and I can't watch Hibike without bawling my eyes out every few eps. The main difference is that this one lacks the solid cast of characters and that affects the world in itself. You'll say 'but this is limited by its run time, you dummy'. Moulin Rouge is equally limited and it is a very simple story. Yet it makes an over-the-top setup presented in a similar way feel more tangible than a simple, every day one most of us have been a part of: high-school. A human drama is at its best when we can believe in the world and characters. It relies on keeping you high-key engaged emotionally or at least mentally. If a movie or a series lacks a hook and you never become truly engaged in the first place, it will be hard to fully appreciate it. Satine has this allure to her, she's very charismatic and you can understand everyone's obsession with her. It's easy to get charmed by a courtesan and that role fits Nicole Kidman like a glove. It all boils down to the fact that I couldn't care about what happened, and probably didn't like the movie that much overall because no matter how nice a world you build, I'd dock a few points if the inhabitants are uninteresting. And it's not all about charisma or the like. You can have a more 'supportive' personality steal the show like Kumiko in Hibike. I couldn't find an anchor - someone to care about. The interactions between said characters have much more depth than your average romcom tou (not to diminish the latter's value) and I appreciate that, but does that really matter if you don't care about the ones interacting? That would work for me in a non-character-driven drama where the story is top-notch or the world is very interesting in itself. I'm sure that I would have liked it so much more if there was at least one character I'd root for.
In spite of my random rambling, I don't hate it. I do, in fact, sort of like it. It is also a movie about a group of friends, one which happens to contain a not-so-sentient AI (more of them?). It's a pretty good human drama at times... and then the police gets involved and THEY'VE GOT A MOPED INSIDE THE BUILDING and the battery's dead. Timeout. A confession, which becomes one of the funniest scenes from the movie for some reason, being a prime example of the limitations Boolean logic suffers from. And then every AI around suddenly understands what's happened to one of their own and they decide to switch sides. It's The Terminator all over again, but with dance and music. And laser beams.
You get the point, it's a fun movie. But it fails as a musical in my book. And it also doesn't have either Ryan Gosling or Emma Stone in it. 6 out of OH YES OH YES OH YES WE BOTH OH YES WE BOTH OH YES WE BOTH REACHED FOR THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN OH YES WE BOTH REACHED FOR THE GUN, a pretty good movie, but a pretty bad musical. Of course, if you take it as satire, it's another story. But you need to understand what makes a good musical in order to satirize it. If you don't, all you end up with is a pointless parody that should at least be funny.
Edit: was a 5 because I cannot count anything that goes beyond 1 hand, it gets complicated :V The individual scores given to each aspect reflected something else.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
 0
Love it
 0
Funny
 0
Confusing
 0
Well-written
 0
Creative
 0Show all
![]()
Apr 11, 2022
*Updated as scans are now available*
I feel like witches are some topic of sorts that never fails to catch at least some attention and this stands true with regards to this medium too. I've previously compared it to Witch Hat Atelier based on the first few chapters as that was the vibe it surrounding it, but I feel like the latter half of the story took a turn for the worst in some regards. It contains some of the usual tropes and themes you see in this type of stories: burn the heretics and so on. I thought it might go a bit of different
...
way at first with the whole witches/Church dichotomy, but it didn't. That's not exactly a bad thing as it was... serviceable at worst. It has its limitations, It'd be pretty hard to craft a more complex world based on the aforementioned dual system in such a short span. Instead, we ended up with some standard themes like discrimination, some sort of 2nd hand theory of criminal liability that was presented as mind-blowing (got a bit triggered, -2 points), even some lowkey anti-xenophobic messages, but they aren't further explored. They're great in themselves, but the execution was a bit lackluster.
It's a very short read tou and I'd say it's worth the time even for the art alone. It is amazing, even mesmerizing at times. It's not one of those works where there is a good panel and it hits you - 'Wow, this looks so cool!' and you prt sc it and share it over social media in exchange for 'based' and other extremely insightful comments. Instead, it is consistent, high-quality artwork, resembling a bit the art of Witch Hat Atelier and it also has some of the nicest-looking covers I've seen. In the latter half, it didn't feel as impactful, but it remained a pleasure to ogle at. And the setup is rather nice, taking place in an alternate modern-day Edinburgh.
You've got an aloof witch taking in an assistant whose magic affinity is too high for his own good. It starts off rather light-hearted, but it becomes a bit gritty towards the end. Nothing wrong with that, I'd say. The transition between these two is somewhat natural, but limited by its length and it feels like some middle chapters are missing. Some plot twists here and there, but that's about it.
Gave it initially a 7, as I've felt like it had a lot of potential to do great things, but in the end it fell a bit flat towards the end. It is still an ok manga, but it lacks that element that would make it stand out from the crowd. It brought nothing new and it didn't execute existing concepts flawlessly either.
TL;DR: At the end of the day, I've somewhat enjoyed it, despite the unexploited potential. Very nice art, serviceable story, likeable characters and a pretty enjoyable manga overall.
Reviewer’s Rating: 5
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Jan 24, 2022
It's unfair of me to review it so early on, but it's equally unfair for it to go unnoticed. Please check this one out if you feel like there's any hint that you might enjoy slice-of-life stories.
Let's talk about 'By the furnace of Miss Alice's house'... Or about furnaces in general. I'm not sure whether it's some sort of quirk, but I've always felt that standing by the fire is fascinating, mesmerizing, in the most primordial way. It is one of the cosiest activities I occasionally partake in. I'm not the biggest outdoor activities enthusiast or the like, but, sometimes, I just feel like heading
...
into the wild, alone or with others. I grab something easy to cook that I can just throw into the open fire, pat myself on the back and call it a day. Potatoes usually suffice. This manga is reminiscent of that feeling: the warmth of the fire, the warmth of another person, contrasted by the solitude and the uneventfulness of wilderness.
Childhood sweethearts, moving to another town to follow a certain professional course, some people come back, others don't and so on. It's the natural course of life. I am from a relatively small town, whose citizens pride themselves in the picturesque countryside surrounding it, the somewhat simpler life, the ability to be in the middle of nature after a 20-minute ride from downtown. These kinds of places are becoming extinct as younger people tend to flock towards big cities and they end up uninhabited. Understandably so though, as the promise of a better life, of happiness, is bound with your financial well-being, but there are circumstances that might make you return. This is one such story: of a girl coming back to her home village to take over her grandma's traditional house. The heart, pun intended, of one such house is one small irori. Warmth. That's what furnaces are for, in part. This is what this manga is. A very warm and cosy place in the middle of nowhere for two childhood friends to reunite and start anew ten years later. However, what I really like about this one, in particular, is the fact that it doesn't feel like something being valuable because it's nostalgic, but as something being nostalgic because it's valuable.
There are not that many chapters out, but, oh boy, after reading the ones that were translated, I had to immediately order the first volume. It doesn't matter if I have to pay 3 times the price of the volume for shipping, I need it. (actually, I've already got it, the shipping's price is justified - great release, slightly bigger than your average Japanese manga release, but not by much, great cover art and Alice's on the spine).
It's a slice-of-life, it's got romance, it's awkward, there's such a nice tension between the two, it's a cooking manga (and the dishes look on-point, chef's kiss, don't read while hungry), the art is really nice, the panelling is on point and the worldbuilding is pretty damn good. That place feels real, the characters that inhabit said world are human-like, their awkward interactions are believable, the fact that the background is not static makes it believable. Add some grounded drama on top plus the fact that the characters are also really likeable and I'm sold. As a disclaimer, the FL is a slight bit older than the ML. That only makes it better I'd say.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Dec 30, 2021
Revue Starlight was one of the series I skipped during summer 2018 and watched at a later date. I ended up really liking it: the pretentious allegory, the idea of life being a stage performance, the critique it brought upon revue (and theatre in general I'd add) and meritocracies to some extent. What's great about this last aspect is the fact that you can tell that it's critique coming from someone supporting the cause, but not agreeing on the means implied, unlike critique for the sake of critique. All in all, a great little series with a rather big cast of cute girls that felt
...
a tad bit underdeveloped and that could do a bit better in terms of making its ideology clear. 8/10, there's space for improvement, mainly by getting closure.
And here's where the movie came into play: it served as a really nice conclusion to some of those characters' arcs. Moreover, I'd say it's the natural next stage for them. In the past few years I've been constantly switching between stages: hs to uni, uni to work, gaming to theatre and back to gaming, drawing to watching movies, series and the like to reading and so on and so forth. At times, I'm rather nostalgic about some of these moments, but looking back on it, I'd say it's a natural transition. It's sometimes tough to accept the fact that you have to move on, but by the time you do, you realize that you're already there and this procedure was, in fact, not that hard. Treasuring those memories is a fundamental aspect of moving on. Actually, not of moving on, but of finding meaning in your life. I could call it, pretentiously, the existentialism of Revue Starlight, pat myself on the shoulder and call it a day.
The movie looked really good, some minor nitpicks here and there, but nonetheless a solid production. I absolutely loved the flashy nature of the series and the movie only adds up on that. Pair that with the fabulous OST and the almost memely-called 'Ikuharaesque' at times direction and I'm sold. As I've previously mentioned, the character arcs featured in those acts were great - a really nice combination of drama: on stage - interpersonal drama, conflicts we have at times with one another and drama as in theatre; backstage - intrapersonal drama, or this thing I like to call what-the-f*ck-am-I-doing-with-my-life-what-is-life drama. Ideologically speaking, this last type of drama is my personal favourite meaning of the word. It's probably because I can relate to some extent to this existential dread switching stages causes. Most of us should as it's the thing modern society agreed upon. Moreover, the postmodern society brought something new: the fact that we are connected which undeniably agravates this dread. We see people transitioning between stages faster or better. We see ourselves in an almost-deprecating light: we might think of ourselves as failures because we are not lawyers or doctors or engineers and so on. Our world is spanning for more than those 50 kilometres it used to. We can see those shameless influencers trying to make a living by making you feel shitty about yourself. We can see those flexers whose sole merit of being where they are is being born under better circumstances. We can see people living much better than ourselves, but we have no idea about the context those images were taken in, about how much work they've put into it, whether their image is just an image or not. Despite that, these last aspects are not something you think about first and foremost. This can lead to dread. This leads to dread. This is one of the reasons people claim that unhappiness has been on the rise for the past few decades among others. Truth is, it's difficult to be happy at all times. Heck, it's not even necessary. But being constantly under the weather would make my life, at least, more miserable. I hate motivational speeches. I absolutely detest reading those inspirational books like 'The Alchemist'. Yet here I am... preaching... in the same manner. (or rather calling something that might look similar at first glance a masterpiece)
Insert the movie in our context. It's not about 'Do more of what makes you happy', 'when you want something, all the universe conspires in helping you to achieve it' and all that bullshit. It's a simple, yet effective: find your own meaning and raison d'etre. I believe that most people are not 100% certain about the choices they make at various crossroads. Back in high school, someone might have thought that a certain profession was his calling, however, after ditching a few years in training that certain someone realizes how much he truly despises said profession. Don't hesitate.
We have acknowledged that life is kinda... dumb and meaningless at times, harsh even. For example, I find living to acquire some wealth I can for my descendants to inherit not that rewarding. I'll die, how will that help me? However, some people might set that as their goal and that's perfectly fine. It's a very noble one in fact. I'm not sure if that's exactly the way the parting sequences, trains and so on and so forth, which where predominant themes and motifs all throughout the movie are to be interpreted and that's great, works of fiction that are open to various interpretations are a blessing for some of us. To each, their own. You do you.
Revue Starlight's movie might not be for everyone, but as a sequel I absolutely loved it. It started as both critique and love letter to the meritocratic and the rather homophobic at times thing that Takarazuka is and it turned out as a really nice take on existentialism and living up to those expectations that we believe the society has from us. For me, it was a really nice belated Christmas gift. If you wonder what drugs I'm on, I'd like to know too.
Reviewer’s Rating: 10
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Oct 7, 2021
Belle is a surprising anime. No, I'm not memeing. Yes, I'll further develop. Might be because I wasn't all that informed about it and I was expecting a standard take on Beauty and the Beast, basically a remake of the classic where the relationship between Belle and the beast is the focus of the movie... or maybe because I didn't expect to get invested in a story of how J-Pop could save the world. Of course, it's far from flawless, it juggles with too many ideas and concepts for its own good and, at times, I couldn't help but 'ugh' at the rather underdeveloped take
...
on cyberbullying or other topics. I wouldn't call it tone-deaf tou. It is still a delicate one when it comes to these matters (plural here because I'm also talking about loss, parental abuse and the like) and despite the idea of making a martyr out of yourself not being something I'd get behind, it is done in a sensible manner and I can respect that.
If you are not moved by anything regarding the story (and I'll be honest, it's far from perfect, but when it comes to themes, motifs, messages and symbolism - basically how it chooses to convey the story - it shines), the OST is surely going to do that, being done in a paying-homage-to-the-original way. For me, the OST did it - I'd not disregard the story tou, it was more of a mixture of both - but I'm one of those people that still listen to various songs from the '91 movie on a daily basis. You know... no one's as well animated as Belle, no one's treating internet as nicely as Belle, no one's OST's as incredibly chic as Belle's, for there's no movie in town half as trendy. Perfect, a pure bombshell! You can ask any Kaho, Takeru or Ryou and they'll tell you what movie they'd prefer to be on. It was reminiscent of it, in classic Beauty and the Beast fashion, yet it was something completely new.
As mentioned, Belle is a gorgeous anime. The maximalism of Mamoru Hosoda's portrayal of the internet is mesmerizing and can be spotted even from the opening sequence, which is, plainly put, beautiful. The true charmer of this movie lies in the details and fully taking advantage of the cinematic experience. Even a single glance at the crowds would show that. Each and every spot is unique. Long shots, it is a huge world, a world where Belle can shine. In contrast, we have a rather locked camera, a 3-min static that gave terrible tummy aches to the more seasoned anime watchers. It genuinely beats me how the same shots are highly praised when they are done in an arthouse movie - see the likes of Mungiu or Bélla Tarr for example, yet they are horrendous in our case. Close-ups, painting up a small world, that is Suzu's real life. The latter slowly expands as Suzu overcomes her struggle. I believe that this movie has some of the finest compositing I've seen in the medium. It's obvious that the cg was a choice; planned from the very beginning, as the work put into it returned some great results.
I'm not going to do a summary of the plot, but I might dwell into some spoilers further on, so beware. I won't spoil you too much tou, but I can guarantee that it makes for an enjoyable experience of new meets old, of 'a tale as old as time' meets near-future tech. You have the mandatory ballroom sequence and the cheesy, heartfelt (and a tad bit subversive, 'tad bit' being an understatement; it's not another Beauty and the Beast, it's a standalone movie; heck, I wouldn't even consider it a romance and that's good) finale I cannot help, but enjoy each time I see done. Of course, it's not your standard Belle getting her beast, but it's Suzu getting her mother, as in she finally understood why she did what she did for a stranger. At the same time, you have a crazed search for a virtual persona's RL identity, dodgy crowd-funders, 'ENHANCE!' software, and a story about fixing the internet (to some extent at least). It is a lot to take in. It's a fairly standard Hosoda work, but it strikes home for me. I am big on both SF and fairy tales, thus I had some hints that I might end up liking it.
It is a story portraying the ugliness of the online world, but with a twist and this twist is the main reason why I'd easily overlook the flaws this series might have: a sincere belief in the potential and beauty of the internet. Most series that are remotely related to the wired share a common trait: they are made by technophobes, for technophobes, for those people are genuinely scared that Bill Gates will steal their personal data and do evil things with it. What will he do? Beats me. But at least Belle has the decency to portray the internet in a positive light, a moderate take, with ups and downs, how it should be, for the internet has been, in part, one of the leading actors of the rapid technological growth we've seen in the past 30 or so years. Of course, it's much more fun to watch a dystopic take, with all the implications, but at the same time, it gets tiring to watch the same bs again and again. Sometimes, I just want to see people do great things on the internet. I just want to see people finding happiness on the internet, for it definitely played a part in mine. I just want to see people being nice to strangers on the internet, just the way Suzu was to Ryuu, and I think this is the reason why I feel that their relationship was developed well enough, for they are strangers... being kind to strangers.
Of course, not everything's pink and nice and so on regarding the internet. There are downsides to it, but if I were to make an analogy to human interactions for example, I'd go for this one. Everybody might seem like a jerk, for it is really difficult to express our thoughts perfectly unless we wrote a whole novel on it. Misunderstandings on top of misunderstandings lead to some rather interesting conversations for the voyeuristic third parties. I want to believe that most people on the internet or outside of it are rather nice and it isn't their intent to harass others, but it's rather difficult when someone just says that 'X anime is bad, why did you like it?'. It's hard for the virtual to be as close a portrayal as the genuine, but, at the same time, it creates a possibility that didn't even exist in the first place: being able to connect to the person you're interacting with. Your world is no longer spanning 30 kilometers. Back to interacting with people, I'm not saying that you should be looking for excuses for everyone - some people are genuine jerks - plus that takes some effort and energy. But maybe that person was just trying to start a friendly debate with you or he was genuinely curious about it and he didn't pay enough attention to how he might come across to others. Just... let it go. I feel like the same is true for the internet, for it's more common and much easier for it to be portrayed as a genuine source of negativity instead of the amazing concept that it is, especially because the underlying tones of a conversation are hard to pick up in written format.
Such is the internet stories paradigm, it's much easier to write a one about the internet being the big bad wolf without the risk of seeming overly idealistic. Belle dodged this pitfall imo. That 'mask off' sequence among others might seem like something out of High School Musical the cynics would laugh at uncontrollably and brand it as cringe-worthy or utter garbage. I loved it. I'd rather be cringe if that's what's deemed cringe nowadays by the lowest common denominator.
It is a story of acceptance of others and yourself, of coming to terms with reality told through a virtual one, of self-actualization. U is another reality. AS is another you. You can live as another you. You can start a new life. You can change the world. But is it truly another you or just a means for you to further develop, to better express yourself?
Overall, I'd say it's an experience that draws a part of its beauty from its flaws. It's not for everybody. It requires something more than surface-level watching in order to be enjoyed. It requires you to start from a simple premise: everything happening in a movie is deliberate, meant to be there. A certain camera movement means something, certain compositing means something, a certain action means something, a certain omission means something. Why do we belittle people so much that we start from the idea that if it doesn't make sense for us, they've probably forgotten something/they're dumb/they couldn't figure out how to create a story like the one in our delusions, what I expected to happen vs what happens? By CinemaSins-like critique standards, this is trash. But so is Return of the Jedi. Do what you want - it's an individual choice how people want to perceive art and obviously, no one else should have a say in that. Neither you nor I.
PS: by far, the best thing Belle does is being a good engine for the train that is anime globalization, especially as it is not that bound by the standard tropes your usual western movie watcher might expect out of anime + it's dropping in A LOT of places right as the metaverse's got kinda mainstream, but why that's bs is a story for another time.
Reviewer’s Rating: 9
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Sep 23, 2021
I came here for yuri smut and the manga delivered exactly that. I found it fairly standard in terms of story and characters, but it lived up to its name so there are no complaints about it from me. The art is very 'moe SoL-ish' for lack of a better term to describe it. This is a story about lust (mostly ours, but the characters' too).
Is it the next queer masterpiece when it comes to depicting a real relationship between two human beings? No.
Is it mostly fetish satisfaction? Yes, and there also some perfectly normal extra fetishes thrown in for the same price
...
like catgirls, maids, bunny girls, hs uniforms, TEACHERS, bloomers, school swimsuits, various school setups and a lot of baths among others. Nothing unorthodox. It's a feast.
Do you need a priest to visit your house with Holy Water and the likes after reading this? No, I don't think so. Despite its lusty plot, it tends to be on the rather wholesome end of the smut spectrum. It is explicit tou, so you might have to call one for that reason alone.
Did it present itself as something else at any point? Not actually. At least not for me, I knew exactly what I was getting into when I've decided to read this manga.
Scissors sort of look like two 7s put together so this gets a 7, standard, it delivered on what it promised the way I expected it to do.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Sep 23, 2021
*This review is for 5 seconds before the Witch falls in love / falling in love with a Witch. I'm not that big of a fan of Demons Harem.*
To be honest, there's not much to review about this one. It's a one-shot + short prequel that can be read in 3 to 4 minutes, so if you are here, reading this, why not give it a go?
It's on the wholesome/cute/funny side. It's sort of... what if we made Tonikawa a fantasy one-shot, but we make it so queer a turtleneck would look good on it. It portrays a classic dense goofball unaware of/unwilling to
...
accept her feelings, thinking she's under the spell of some charm from a witch. Well, she actually was charmed by the witch, but... Moving on, the only downside of this series besides the rather standard narrative is the fact that we don't get to see more of it. I need more of this fluff, especially after the hints of that last panel. Oh, worth mentioning, I also liked the interactions between our lead and the boy from the shop and getting a decent supporting cast that emphasizes your main cast's characteristics is worthy of praise in one-shots.
If you enjoyed it, you could also check out the Mage & Demon Queen webtoon. It's got the same vibe.
Reviewer’s Rating: 8
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Apr 6, 2021
Crazy Food Truck... Is probably one of the most American experiences in the medium (the most stereotypical way possible, resembling a 90s eastern European sitcom that got cancelled half-way through season 2, but that's not exactly a bad thing if you're into borderline campy stuff). It is a comedy, but I did not feel like laughing, instead I felt like smirking all along. As such, I'm trying to convince you, the potential reader, to give it a shot. You have guns, you have good looking food in industrial quantities, some over-the-top occurrences, tits and a manly man mc. Disgusting. If you're not sold, keep reading.
The
...
character design is fine overall. I like Gordon's tbh, because despite being the most cliché middle-aged badass daddy character, the mangaka managed to create a very solid, recognizable and likeable one. He's basically the manga version of a Harley-owning dad.
The set-up could be summed up as Mad Max meets Gordon Ramsay's food truck (if this were a thing). It is a post-apocalyptic scenario, and the backgrounds depict that quite well. They are not very detailed, but the art, despite being a bit rough, is nice. Even though it's only 6 chapters long at the time of the preview, we've already got some nice panels and spreads. I still remember the 'Blue Lake City' one as it somehow managed to build upon the idea of desolation, despite its simplicity. Oh and there are also some good action panels and the coloured pages we get are a treat. Plus the food is looking fine too (especially that BLT.. It stuck with me).
Paneling is pretty good, it's a well-done series and I didn't manage to find any instance that'd disrupt my reading experience, but at the same time, it's nothing to write home about tbh.
What stood out for me first in this series: the worldbuilding as the way it's done is rather interesting, using all means available. We see some settlements and the life of those people, what professions are in demand, the fact that fish are meant to fly or swim through the sand and that there are carnivorous trees that use water as bait. It starts as an rather eccentric food-action manga and it keeps that up, more questions being asked each chapter. Who is 'I'm hungry'? Where did she come from? Why is she healing so fast? And then it slams in an Onsen episode. I'd say it's a really hectic series (in a good way). At times, it has some realist moments, but in the next few pages it 180s and we have people bringing spoons to a katana fight. Maybe I've exaggerated a bit, it's not that eccentric, but it is definitely a really fun experience.
Moreover, I really liked the pace this was going at. It's really easy to follow, it doesn't get boring and it's not too fast either. If it were to be faster-paced, there is a chance the world would fall apart and the plot would have to suffer. However, we haven't seen that much of the plot, besides collecting more and more questions with each chapter. I need to see more chapters of this to get a better grasp of the story, but so far I'd say it's been a solid start and it was at least an intriguing world and story that managed to pull me in.
When it comes to characters, we have Gordon, a runaway from the army in his 40s who's quite a man-of-action I'd say. Behaviour-wise... Everyone's making the Gordon Ramsay jokes for a reason. I mean even to 'I'm hungry' he behaves in a similar manner Gordon does with kids. Oh.. You precious little thing, are you hungry? I mean both being badass daddies that cook and named Gordon is already enough to make those jokes, right? Putting that aside, I really like his character. He's cool, collected, mysterious and I can't help, but wonder what his background is.
And then we have 'I'm hungry!' which Gordon picks up after almost running her over while she was sleeping in the middle of the road. She's a 19 year old gourmet, human or not as her origin is quite foggy at the moment. She's the main addresser of the ecchi, but I'd argue it's rather mild, well-done and tasteful. In case you're worried about the age gap, as he could be her father, at the moment Gordon doesn't even care that much about it and he's not flustered, but uncomfortable if she's naked, and I really liked this aspect.
Moreover, I loved the fact that the characters portrayed as antagonists actually try solving the problem peacefully, instead of taking a kill-on-sight approach. For an over-the-top premise and story as this, they actually are shockingly humane. We don't even know if they are the 'bad guys' in the first place and they don't feel like a mean to further the plot. It's just so early into the series, but we've even got some development for the characters. I didn't expect there to be any, as I feel like eccentric manga works without it quite well, but it was definitely a welcome surprise.
All in all, in case it wasn't obvious, I really like this manga and I think others would do too. It's not a convoluted story or anything among those lines, but it is pure entertainment at the moment. I'd say the first chapter's the only one with a bit more ecchi in it, so even if you dislike that, but like fiction that doesn't take itself too seriously and ends up being plain boring or a history book, go for it. I mean... I'd argue there are series that don't have the tag that have more fan service, but this doesn't shy away from displaying boobs so it's understandable why the tag's there. I'm starting to get the gist of manga and I'd call it unique. I haven't come across a similar one so far. Probably not being what I tend to read plays a part in that, but if someone who's not that big into this type of manga recommends it, I'd say it's worth a shot.
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Apr 5, 2021
I made 2 big mistakes I'll never forget in this lifetime: first was when I first-picked Sona in my last promo game and second... when I thought of Precure as a series that is for welp young girls or really hardcore mahou shoujo fans only.
As a disclaimer, I've watched to the end Heartcatch only (and I'll be probably looked down upon by the true fans for that), tried a few other random seasons (ended up postponing them), started Hugtto recently (and I'm loving it), got the gist regarding how the series works and plan to watch a few more. I'm rather new to the
...
franchise, but there's something I find really charming about it. It is like a return to the roots so to speak. Every Sunday I wake up (or before I go to sleep sometimes as I'm not that functional) and watch THE episode. Now, I'm not thirteen, but that's exactly how I feel. It's got this rather fanciful atmosphere surrounding it and I want more people to give it a shot.
Production 2.1/3
I really like the character design (especially Asuka). I feel like they are really well done and each and every one of them has got some peculiarities that make it shine brighter. Moreover, even the supporting cast's looking pretty good. Now, when it comes to a staple in the genre, the transformation scenes, they were pretty damn solid (despite being a bit stiff), especially Asuka's with that Trigger vibe going on. They are vivid and full of energy plus that 'Let's make-up!' catchphrase has somehow... Caught me in.
The art style is very suitable. Even watching a scene out of context, you'd know this is a magical girls show. It's really colourful and pleasant, as long as you don't mind a more tropical palette. Composition-wise the series is doing fine too, as the 3dcg (which is quite well done) is not that blatant and it blends in really well with the other elements of the show. The framing's been pretty good too. What stood out the most for me were maybe some of the shots from the fight scenes and those 'cool guys don't look at explosions' poses after each victory, which I found rather quirky and unique. I'm not used to seeing those in an anime, but I don't mind them at all. They actually kind of remind me of some video games.
Story 1.2/2
What you have to understand is that Precure is aimed at kids. As such it follows a format that is easy to watch and doesn't require some 200iq charts to remember what's going on. Kids don't mind the episodic format (at least in the early parts from what I've seen + they fit together quite nicely). Don't expect to find a masterpiece of a story that you'll dissect with dem bois on a 2005 forum, each coming with a new theory for what Manatsu meant when she said she wants to tropica-shine, especially as the series' focal point is the relationship between its cast and how they interact with each other, not the plot. However, you can expect a really fun light-hearted adventure that even the villains don't take that seriously. Even though Precure can really do drama, so far this feels like a more fun and energetic season. Moreover, for the aforementioned reason the pacing of each episode's been really good so far. If it were too slow, kids would easily get bored, while if it were too fast they wouldn't follow it.
The show is pretty action packed, but it is a bit too early to make too many remarks regarding other aspects of it, as I have no idea what path this will take. However, from what I've seen so far, the first episode after introductions was a pleasant surprise.
Characters 0.6/1
They are likeable and, despite the black-and-white morality (Laura's is a bit questionable at times and that's perfect, I'd add^^) that's pretty strong within this series, they've all got their own personalities. They have their strengths and obviously their weaknesses. The precures are fun to watch while interacting with each other as they are well-balanced as a cast and Laura's banter is pretty good. The only thing I'm not the biggest fan of is Manatsu's overbearing at times personality. That's pretty standard for pink cures (or so I'm told), but she's still a bit too much. To be fair, even the rest are pretty standard Precure deal when it comes to characters/backstories and that's exactly why this can work as a starting point into the series. On the other hand, Asuka's cool chara's a really nice addition.
Another thing I really liked is that the villains are not that serious about their job. I've always felt like life, in general, shouldn't be treated too formally as you'll miss on a lot of things. The 'it is what it is' attitude is pretty healthy I'd say, as long as you can keep it in check. Same thing can be said about them, as they don't seem that motivated (quite ironically) to dry everyone's motivation.
Sound 0.7/1
I like the op and I find it to be quite a good match for the overall tone of the show. The ed's nice too and the overall sound design was good. The voice acting is really good and I'm glad that Eripiyo's getting so many big roles lately, as she totally killed it in Oshi ga Budo. I'm quite shocked to see her fit so many different roles so well.
Enjoyment 2.4/3
This is what Precure is: a really enjoyable experience that every anime fan should at least try. I feel like this would be a great starting point as watching this on a weekly basis adds quite a few to the series' fanciful feel (at least for me it does), instead of binging it in a few days when it's over. At the moment, it doesn't look like the best Precure season to be completely honest, but this can change easily. It might not be everyone's cup of tea, as it is a mixture of light-hearted comedy, drama and action aimed at kids, but please give this a chance. Don't disregard it because of its premise, as you might end up actually liking it. I didn't grow up with it or anything like that, as such you can't blame it on nostalgia, but I feel like Precure overall is a series that's done dirty by the west.
I haven't seen that much Precure. I'm not a hardcore fan and maybe my thoughts about this season and series are not on-point, but I feel like the opinion of a newcomer might matter to potential newcomers mainly because there are people that feel disheartened when a huge fan of a show recommends it and discard it as bias. As an anime, I wouldn't say it's the second coming of Jesus, but as an experience, this is definitely worth every second.
T= 7
Reviewer’s Rating: 7
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
![]()
Mar 26, 2021
This was, at the time of the review, available on a Youtube account going by the same name as the series. As the synopsis states, it is a short ONA released by a town with a population of almost 19.000 which commemorates the 10-year anniversary of the 2011 Tohoku earthquake and tsunami. Now, I have no idea what those people went through back then as I live in a rather safe from those calamities area, but I'd say it did a pretty good job at portraying both the context and the message even to the likes of me.
Production 1.5/3 (5)
I won't lie. The production wasn't
...
stellar. It was mediocre at best, considering the background of how this came into existence. It has this rough art style, which I like for some reason. It looks like those sketches you usually do 2-3 years in, but at least they are easy to animate (and I suppose this did not have the budget of the latest Fate movies vOv). So yeah.. I'll cut it some slack. It would be more appropriate to compare it to an animation school project instead. In other words, if you don't mind the rather indie look, go for it.
Story 1.4/2 (7)
The story was pretty straight-forward. It was not innovative, but, unlike Nihon Chinbotsu 2020 (which I found truly horrendous), this didn't try to capitalize on the shock factor. Instead it chose the 'I have no idea what's happening -> it doesn't look that bad -> ok, maybe our city's destroyed' route.
It didn't even spend that much time on how atrocious the earthquake and tsunami have been. The message wasn't 'earthquake bad, the world is ending' and that was great. We've got through it, we've rebuilt our small haven and we moved on. Now that's a much more respectable take on the ordeal. Imho, this mentality is what managed to bounce Japan back from what happened and I found this series to be a pretty good portrayal of it, even thought it didn't go in-depth on the aforementioned aspects.
Characters 0.5/1 (5)
How much can you see in such a short time? To be honest, the characters were average Joes and that's perfect. The glasses girl was pretty much a self-insert for the audience. Look how far we've managed to get in those 10 years.
Sound 0.6/1 (6)
Nothing peculiar in this regard either, but the voice acting was rather good. Unexpectedly good considering the overall production and the fact that it has been done by a small town.
Enjoyment 1.8/3 (6)
I am not the target audience, but, despite that and the fact that I cannot fully comprehend the fear of calamities, I found the message and the path this took in order to convey it to be rather beautiful. 'It doesn't matter what happens in your daily life, what's important is getting over it' - Costel, compactor roller operator.
Total = 5.8 (fine)
Rating a commemorative series such as this on a normal scale is unfair, but I consider it good for its kind. It made me think about what happened and that was its purpose. Unlike Nihon Chinbotsu, this is not so stupid you can't take it seriously and it also has a meaningful message.
Reviewer’s Rating: 6
What did you think of this review?
Nice
0
Love it
0
Funny
0
Confusing
0
Well-written
0
Creative
0Show all
|
