K-ON!
| K-on is a good SOL anime but a poor music show They drank more tea in this anime than they actually played music, I believe there was more music in one episode of You lie in April, kids on the slope and Sound Euphonium than the entirety of K-on, so I'm wondering why this was marketed as a music anime rather than more of SOL antics type of show Cause anyone who wants to watch this show for its music rather than it's SOL antics 9/10 of them are going to get disappointed.  |
Cestlavie_Oct 24, 2022 1:46 AM
| Every CGDCT anime must have some sort of twist or theme it is centered about. Yuru Camp has camping, Non Non Biyori has country setting, K-ON has music. |
 |
Conor1203 said: Wdym the music goes hella hard in K-On imo both are highlights of the show Fuwa Fuwa Time can only carry so much I'm afraid. I mean what other catchy songs did they perform |
Cestlavie_ said: K-on is a good SOL anime but a poor music show They drank more tea in this anime than they actually played music, I believe there was more music in one episode of You lie in April, kids on the slope and Sound Euphonium than the entirety of K-on, so I'm wondering why this was marketed as a music anime rather than more of SOL antiques type of show Cause anyone who wants to watch this show for its music rather than it's SOL antiques 9/10 of them are going to get disappointed. If you are saying this then you didn't actually understand this show |
| I wasn't really expecting a lot of music in the anime, I watched it to see why people liked it. |
 |
WiskleGEX said: Cestlavie_ said: K-on is a good SOL anime but a poor music show They drank more tea in this anime than they actually played music, I believe there was more music in one episode of You lie in April, kids on the slope and Sound Euphonium than the entirety of K-on, so I'm wondering why this was marketed as a music anime rather than more of SOL antiques type of show Cause anyone who wants to watch this show for its music rather than it's SOL antiques 9/10 of them are going to get disappointed. If you are saying this then you didn't actually understand this show So you want to tell me this is a truly good "music" anime K-on is about 4 girls going through high school with their cute SOL antiques what more is there to understand? |
Cestlavie_ said: Conor1203 said: Wdym the music goes hella hard in K-On imo both are highlights of the show Fuwa Fuwa Time can only carry so much I'm afraid. I mean what other catchy songs did they perform Tbf when they played U & I for the first time was the most emotional moment of the show for me. |
Cestlavie_ said: K-on is a good SOL anime but a poor music show They drank more tea in this anime than they actually played music, I believe there was more music in one episode of You lie in April, kids on the slope and Sound Euphonium than the entirety of K-on, so I'm wondering why this was marketed as a music anime rather than more of SOL antiques type of show Cause anyone who wants to watch this show for its music rather than it's SOL antiques 9/10 of them are going to get disappointed. I think you've failed as as a perceptive and comprehensive human being |
| https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ [WATCH THIS^^^] |
sonu711 said: Cestlavie_ said: K-on is a good SOL anime but a poor music show They drank more tea in this anime than they actually played music, I believe there was more music in one episode of You lie in April, kids on the slope and Sound Euphonium than the entirety of K-on, so I'm wondering why this was marketed as a music anime rather than more of SOL antiques type of show Cause anyone who wants to watch this show for its music rather than it's SOL antiques 9/10 of them are going to get disappointed. I think you've failed as as a perceptive and comprehensive human being LoL the K-ontards really coming after me . |
VampireLord1024 said: I wasn't really expecting a lot of music in the anime, I watched it to see why people liked it. As for me I watched it expecting it to be a musical Anime and was a bit disappointed, some concerts even get off screened. if it was advertised as more SOL I won't have ended up expecting what I didn't get |
your statement was easily wrong. There are multiple good songs in K-on which you were unable to hear |
| https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ [WATCH THIS^^^] |
Broximeuh said: Cestlavie_ said: Fuwa Fuwa Time can only carry so much I'm afraid. I mean what other catchy songs did they perform Tbf when they played U & I for the first time was the most emotional moment of the show for me. true. this guy just doesn't understand |
| https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ [WATCH THIS^^^] |
sonu711 said: your statement was easily wrong. There are multiple good songs in K-on which you were unable to hear You can count on one hand the nos of times they performed in this anime it had 40 episodes in total and like what three performances in all. the fact that no one has voted for music says something as well 😂 |
| i officially declare that this is both, knowing that this is a musical anime with a musical group playing the main roles! |
 |
Cestlavie_ said: sonu711 said: your statement was easily wrong. There are multiple good songs in K-on which you were unable to hear You can count on one hand the nos of times they performed in this anime it had 40 episodes in total and like what three performances in all. the fact that no one has voted for music says something as well 😂 that's because you didn't fucking put the 'both' button. People, unlike you enjoy the show. |
| https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ [WATCH THIS^^^] |
sonu711 said: Cestlavie_ said: You can count on one hand the nos of times they performed in this anime it had 40 episodes in total and like what three performances in all. the fact that no one has voted for music says something as well 😂 that's because you didn't fucking put the 'both' button. People, unlike you enjoy the show. Putting a 'both' option will defeat the purpose of finding out which one the fandom liked most and I still gave both seasons of K-on a 7 so I didn't dislike the show |
Cestlavie_ said: sonu711 said: that's because you didn't fucking put the 'both' button. People, unlike you enjoy the show. Putting a 'both' option will defeat the purpose of finding out which one the fandom liked most and I still gave both seasons of K-on a 7 so I didn't dislike the show I don't think so. majority of the people liked both of the aspects rather than liking only one aspect. You're the minority of the people who came for just one aspect and got disappointed. |
| https://youtu.be/dQw4w9WgXcQ [WATCH THIS^^^] |
| Yeah... I don't think your claim that this was marketed as a more pure music show than a CGDCT SOL type show really holds any water. |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
LostSpectre said: Yeah... I don't think your claim that this was marketed as a more pure music show than a CGDCT SOL type show really holds any water. From the Trailer, to the endings and even the synopsis it all seems more music oriented than SOL |
Cestlavie_ said: It really doesn't, though. LostSpectre said: Yeah... I don't think your claim that this was marketed as a more pure music show than a CGDCT SOL type show really holds any water. From the Trailer, to the endings and even the synopsis it all seems more music oriented than SOL |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
LostSpectre said: Cestlavie_ said: It really doesn't, though. From the Trailer, to the endings and even the synopsis it all seems more music oriented than SOL so u telling me u came into this show expecting a show full of antics than actual musical performance |
| I enjoyed the SOL more but I really like the music and pretty regularly listen to kon music outside of the anime, I think you should have an option to vote for both tbh |
Call me Ren  |
Cestlavie_ said: If we're talking about a more modern perspective it's an obvious CGDCT/SOL show at heart, but in 2009? I can't say that for certain. LostSpectre said: It really doesn't, though. so u telling me u came into this show expecting a show full of antics than actual musical performance |
| If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that. |
| Its an anime about a music club actually, so club activities in general are also a focus |
  |
Cestlavie_ said: VampireLord1024 said: I wasn't really expecting a lot of music in the anime, I watched it to see why people liked it. As for me I watched it expecting it to be a musical Anime and was a bit disappointed, some concerts even get off screened. if it was advertised as more SOL I won't have ended up expecting what I didn't get I thought maybe the girls would practice more & make more songs, but I enjoyed the anime either way. |
|
Broximeuh said: Cestlavie_ said: Fuwa Fuwa Time can only carry so much I'm afraid. I mean what other catchy songs did they perform Tbf when they played U & I for the first time was the most emotional moment of the show for me. For me too. Also, in later series with Tenshi ni Fureta Yo. |
      Bonus candies:  |
| The show goes out of its way to point out how they just goof off all the time and never actually practice. |
-insert NGE meme here- |
Subham0464 said: What are you talking about? Can you name other shows where you have such unique are easily recognisable original songs? U&I, fuwa fuwa time, my love is like a stapler, Gohan wa okazu, and others, and then there are absolute bangers that are op and the eds...hiw much more music do you want? Every Love Live iteration |
| I thought this was a music anime. I was wrong. It was a show about lazy brats doing nothing but drink tea and never practice or put in hard work… and still succeed. Hated it with all my heart and soul. |
sonu711 said: Cestlavie_ said: K-on is a good SOL anime but a poor music show They drank more tea in this anime than they actually played music, I believe there was more music in one episode of You lie in April, kids on the slope and Sound Euphonium than the entirety of K-on, so I'm wondering why this was marketed as a music anime rather than more of SOL antiques type of show Cause anyone who wants to watch this show for its music rather than it's SOL antiques 9/10 of them are going to get disappointed. I think you've failed as as a perceptive and comprehensive human being Dude chill, they were giving valid reflection. Who hurt you Edit: grammar |
Subham0464 said: RHinoManer22 said: Is the bar as low as hell for you If you really including opening and endings when every anime even non music themed have that. This show had 40 episodes and a movie and u really think only that is appropriate for a music themed anime Have u seen you lie in April Yes please remind me how every episode of your lie in April was purely dedicated to music. And man, it had soo many songs other than op1 that people still listen to. if I remember correctly You lie in April had a performance like once every three episodes While there was only one real performance in the first season of K-on |
More topics from this board
Poll: » K-ON! Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )game8910 - Jun 4, 2009 |
233 |
by The_Neeko
»»
Apr 1, 8:37 AM |
|
Poll: » K-ON! Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Veronin - Apr 2, 2009 |
598 |
by piratini
»»
Mar 16, 1:58 AM |
|
Poll: » K-ON! Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )DaBigD - Jun 25, 2009 |
344 |
by bubba460z
»»
Mar 3, 3:22 PM |
|
Poll: » K-ON! Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )game8910 - Jun 18, 2009 |
314 |
by bubba460z
»»
Mar 3, 2:59 PM |
|
Poll: » K-ON! Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )DaBigD - Jun 11, 2009 |
199 |
by bubba460z
»»
Mar 3, 2:39 PM |