YAHOOGAYCHATROOM's Profile
- Last OnlineSep 30, 2022 4:43 AM
- JoinedMar 3, 2022
RSS Feeds
Don't even talk to me if you haven't played BattleTanx on N64
My truth:
- Democracy, along with being the worst political system, is the worst gauge of anime quality
- Lowbrow > highbrow > middlebrow
- There's no such thing as derivative art, everything is stolen from something else.
- Yoshiaki Kawajiri >>>>> Miyazaki
- Miyazaki hasn't made one good movie in his 700 years alive on earth
- NGE would have been better if Anno was fired
Rating scale:
10: pure gestalt/masterpiece (M.D. Geist, Musashi Gundoh, Kill Me Baby, etc)
(Anything less is unwatchable)
more than a few seconds of CGI = instant drop
skin fang = instant drop
made after 2009 = instant drop
|
Statistics
Anime Stats
Days: 27.8
Mean Score:
5.89
- Total Entries164
- Rewatched0
- Episodes1,551
Last Anime Updates
Ex-Arm
Dropped
-/12
· Scored
2
Manga Stats
Days: 1.1
Mean Score:
5.44
- Total Entries10
- Reread0
- Chapters189
- Volumes14
Last Manga Updates
Majeh
Dropped
-/414
· Scored
5
Favorites
Anime (10)
Character (7)
All Comments (45) Comments
Are you tempting fate a bit intentionally?
:-!
>Can you make a video essay on this?
Yeah...but I fear the sheer masculinity would offend those easily offended peoples (you know, the same people who cried when Elon Musk bought the twit machine).
See? Much more effective :-!
It is pretty petty, you gotta admit.
With Beastars... well, you're right about your points of the more traditional 2D style. But if we look at CGI from a point of the production as whole, while 2D could achieve more aesthetically looking result, it would take considerably more effort (and budget I imagine) with the inhuman character designs. So if we suppose the studio has same budget whether they do 2D or 3D, I prefer working 3D over low quality 2D. I'm not saing Beastars has amazing animation, but I would say it has a good one.
There's also stuff like gdgd Fairies, Funny Pets or Popee the Performer where 2D wouldn't really work for the semi-ironic surreal nature.
My point being, even if traditional animation might be better, that doesn't mean CG is by default no good. Just not ideal - but that might still be good, just less.
Personally I'm a big fan of the oldschool cell animation, especially if the anime gets a remastered HD release, that's just beautiful to look at, but yeah, they don't make them like they used to, lol.
My point was, CG and anime can look passable and that it's not an automatic fail, like you've already decided. You legit go into everything just automatically assuming the worst, don't you?
Well, not like I didn't know that. Why don't you post again and actually tackle other people's counter points, by the way?