Yeah, I don´t think there are too many authors, especially in big magazines like the WSJ, who plan their manga to end in less than 100 chapters. Is very sad when a manga you like, which has a nice premise and good characters, is suddenly axed. It happened to me with Kisaragi-san had a Piercing Gaze as I think I mentioned before; I was shocked when I saw the manga ended after 20 chapters since there were initially hints the manga was going to be a bit longer.
I read some weeks ago the manga Seishun Soukanzu; it was very crappy, to be honest, but after reaching the final chapter it was crystal clear the manga was axed. Not the biggest loss, but still sad that the authors weren´t able to develop the story a bit further.
I heard of it, such a disappointment; I read the plot of Tenmaku Cinema and it caught my attention a lot. I was about to start it when I saw it was axed. What was Do Retry about? I don´t think I heard of it before.
I feel Mission Yozakura Family time is coming; the manga was very entertaining, and it was a good mix of comedy and drama. I consider the story went downhill ever since the twin children of the main couple appeared.
I love One Piece, but I wonder if it would have had the same look today as it did back in 1997. Demon Slayer's beginning was promising in my opinion, especially the initial fight between Tanjirou and Giyuu for Nezuko´s survival; moreover, JJK's premise was also interesting, especially the part about the main character's life pending approval by the higher-ups.
I agree with you; WSJ is canceling many good and promising manga just because the authors take their time developing the world and the characters. If the editorial keeps doing that, the popularity of other series is not going to be enough to save them.
That´s very sad to hear; I saw it was axed after 36 chapters. Did it have a decent finale at least?
I am starting to agree with what you said about the WSJ not handling properly manga and their writers; or at least everyone is pushed to publish when they aren´t in good health with the threat that there is backup already prepared.
I remember I started reading on a site that has, for instance, just 40 chapters, then I jumped into another one that had 60, then the original one updated faster than the second one; to sum up, it was a mess and very unorganized. I did not watch the anime, but I loved the opening song; Nano never disappoints. I do recall the final scene I saw before stop reading the manga; it was near the end, and there was an upcoming fight between Sakamoto and Oda.
Aside from One Piece, My Hero Academia, and Black Clover, I am reading Mission Yozakura Family and The Ichinose Family Deadly Sins; I have to say that I initially enjoyed Mission Yozakura Family quite a lot, the mix between comedy and action was very entertaining, but lately, I feel the story has lost its appeal, especially since the two MC were replaced. Ichinose Family is very interesting and curious, it was written by the same author as Takopi´s Original Sin; however, it feels like a story that works better for a short period, otherwise it would feel dragged.
I read Mashle as well, and I found the comedy amazing; it was really a combination between Harry Potter and One Punch Man hahaha. Sadly, only the first part was unique and memorable, the later part felt weak.
I have read very good things about Fabricant 100, I may pick it to see how it is. I hope it doesn´t get axed though.
I noticed you removed your profile picture, it is kind of cute the way MAL has a default image for when someone removes or doesn´t have a picture hahaha; do you have something in mind for what you want?
Just like the first anime series wasn´t perfect, the movies also have flaws of course; nevertheless, the movies are very enjoyable by themselves, just keep in mind that they aren´t remastered versions of the anime, but their own story. At the end of the day, is up to you if you like them; I hope you have a good time watching them.
I knew Ayashimon way before I started reading Jigokuraku; I was aware the former was axed after being reported as not selling well, and I was shocked when I learned it was written by the same author as the latter. I agree with you on that, I cannot Yuuji created that was as bad as it was stated; I have read reviews and checked individual scores, and both are actually good. I don´t know how things work in the WSJ editorial department, but I am aware of the amount of manga canceled in the past years; I was reading Aliens Area out of curiosity and when I checked it was canceled as well.
For some comments I have read Ayashimon was a success outside of Japan, but it was competing against other battle shounen stories that were more popular at the time, and it was overlooked by the target country.
I enjoy survival game manga; they tend to be a bit trashy but they are my guilty pleasure hahaha. I was interested because I saw a lot of advertisements, and because I liked your honesty about Deatte I might check it to confirm it; I am currently watching Houseki no Kuni aside from the seasonal anime currently airing, so I might pick it up after a while to confirm your points.
I read Btooom! some time ago while it was still being published; I liked the art style, the character design, the background accuracy, and the side plot with the people outside of the island. Sadly, I lost track of which chapter I was because I did not use MAL at the time.
Don´t worry, I am planning to change my current profile picture, but I don´t like stealing; as the proverb says, early birds get the worm hahaha.
By the way, I saw you are currently reading Fabricant 100, how it is going? I am curious because I am reading some of the current line-ups of the WSJ; something interesting is that several of the current manga doesn´t have good MAL scores.
I love the Angel's design a lot; especially because during the second half they started getting more powerful and destructive. The first Rebuild movie is completely similar to the anime; the first three Angels that appeared in the anime appear in the movie, with newer designs, and the story is mostly the same, with the addition that Kaworu was introduced at the end of it, even before Asuka. Later on, some newer angels appear alongside new characters and Evangelion robots. By the end of the second movie, the story changes differ from the anime, and the third and fourth movies are original; the climax of the fourth movie is a linker, but I will not develop more than to avoid spoilers hahaha. In conclusion, there are very interesting, well-animated, and not bad at all.
Fair enough, thanks for your opinion. I have heard a lot about how the manga goes downhill after a while and wastes all the potential and hype the beginning created. I am going to read it anyways to see it by myself since I like nice art and drawing; I am considering reading Ayashimon because it was also canceled after being labeled the future of the Shounen Jump alongside Honomieru Shounen. Nevertheless, it is sad to hear it had potential and just waste it.
I agree, the picture is amazing and very detailed. I liked the tattoos and they remind me a lot of the marks Nezuko had on Kimetsu no Yaiba, the oni mask looks amazing as well; overall, it feels like a well-drawn cover for some manga chapter.
I noticed you watched Deatte 5-byou de Battle, what is your opinion of it? It called my attention a while ago because a lot of advertisements for the anime appeared on my social medial accounts, and on the site I watch anime.
Hello, and thank you for accepting my friend request; it is a pleasure to meet you :)
I like your profile picture, is it a character from an anime or manga maybe?
Evangelion is an amazing anime; I finished the Rebuild of Evangelion movies a while ago, and they were very unique and entertaining. Who is your favorite character from the anime?
I noticed you read Honomieru Shounen; it called my attention so I added it to my PTR list a while ago. I am aware it was axed, but I am still interested in hearing other's perspectives, how would you describe it?
Recent CGI in animated series has seen improvements. I haven't watched it, but that League of Legends show gets praise for its CGI, which looks hand-drawn sometimes.
I have mixed feelings about the 80s VHD movie, but Bloodlust is Madhouse at their best. They were kings of their craft, I can't believe how beautiful that film is.
All Comments (33) Comments
I read some weeks ago the manga Seishun Soukanzu; it was very crappy, to be honest, but after reaching the final chapter it was crystal clear the manga was axed. Not the biggest loss, but still sad that the authors weren´t able to develop the story a bit further.
I heard of it, such a disappointment; I read the plot of Tenmaku Cinema and it caught my attention a lot. I was about to start it when I saw it was axed. What was Do Retry about? I don´t think I heard of it before.
I feel Mission Yozakura Family time is coming; the manga was very entertaining, and it was a good mix of comedy and drama. I consider the story went downhill ever since the twin children of the main couple appeared.
I love One Piece, but I wonder if it would have had the same look today as it did back in 1997. Demon Slayer's beginning was promising in my opinion, especially the initial fight between Tanjirou and Giyuu for Nezuko´s survival; moreover, JJK's premise was also interesting, especially the part about the main character's life pending approval by the higher-ups.
I agree with you; WSJ is canceling many good and promising manga just because the authors take their time developing the world and the characters. If the editorial keeps doing that, the popularity of other series is not going to be enough to save them.
Hahaha, really? Very nice camera.
I am starting to agree with what you said about the WSJ not handling properly manga and their writers; or at least everyone is pushed to publish when they aren´t in good health with the threat that there is backup already prepared.
Nice profile picture by the way.
Aside from One Piece, My Hero Academia, and Black Clover, I am reading Mission Yozakura Family and The Ichinose Family Deadly Sins; I have to say that I initially enjoyed Mission Yozakura Family quite a lot, the mix between comedy and action was very entertaining, but lately, I feel the story has lost its appeal, especially since the two MC were replaced. Ichinose Family is very interesting and curious, it was written by the same author as Takopi´s Original Sin; however, it feels like a story that works better for a short period, otherwise it would feel dragged.
I read Mashle as well, and I found the comedy amazing; it was really a combination between Harry Potter and One Punch Man hahaha. Sadly, only the first part was unique and memorable, the later part felt weak.
I have read very good things about Fabricant 100, I may pick it to see how it is. I hope it doesn´t get axed though.
I noticed you removed your profile picture, it is kind of cute the way MAL has a default image for when someone removes or doesn´t have a picture hahaha; do you have something in mind for what you want?
I knew Ayashimon way before I started reading Jigokuraku; I was aware the former was axed after being reported as not selling well, and I was shocked when I learned it was written by the same author as the latter. I agree with you on that, I cannot Yuuji created that was as bad as it was stated; I have read reviews and checked individual scores, and both are actually good. I don´t know how things work in the WSJ editorial department, but I am aware of the amount of manga canceled in the past years; I was reading Aliens Area out of curiosity and when I checked it was canceled as well.
For some comments I have read Ayashimon was a success outside of Japan, but it was competing against other battle shounen stories that were more popular at the time, and it was overlooked by the target country.
I enjoy survival game manga; they tend to be a bit trashy but they are my guilty pleasure hahaha. I was interested because I saw a lot of advertisements, and because I liked your honesty about Deatte I might check it to confirm it; I am currently watching Houseki no Kuni aside from the seasonal anime currently airing, so I might pick it up after a while to confirm your points.
I read Btooom! some time ago while it was still being published; I liked the art style, the character design, the background accuracy, and the side plot with the people outside of the island. Sadly, I lost track of which chapter I was because I did not use MAL at the time.
Don´t worry, I am planning to change my current profile picture, but I don´t like stealing; as the proverb says, early birds get the worm hahaha.
By the way, I saw you are currently reading Fabricant 100, how it is going? I am curious because I am reading some of the current line-ups of the WSJ; something interesting is that several of the current manga doesn´t have good MAL scores.
I love the Angel's design a lot; especially because during the second half they started getting more powerful and destructive. The first Rebuild movie is completely similar to the anime; the first three Angels that appeared in the anime appear in the movie, with newer designs, and the story is mostly the same, with the addition that Kaworu was introduced at the end of it, even before Asuka. Later on, some newer angels appear alongside new characters and Evangelion robots. By the end of the second movie, the story changes differ from the anime, and the third and fourth movies are original; the climax of the fourth movie is a linker, but I will not develop more than to avoid spoilers hahaha. In conclusion, there are very interesting, well-animated, and not bad at all.
Fair enough, thanks for your opinion. I have heard a lot about how the manga goes downhill after a while and wastes all the potential and hype the beginning created. I am going to read it anyways to see it by myself since I like nice art and drawing; I am considering reading Ayashimon because it was also canceled after being labeled the future of the Shounen Jump alongside Honomieru Shounen. Nevertheless, it is sad to hear it had potential and just waste it.
I agree, the picture is amazing and very detailed. I liked the tattoos and they remind me a lot of the marks Nezuko had on Kimetsu no Yaiba, the oni mask looks amazing as well; overall, it feels like a well-drawn cover for some manga chapter.
I noticed you watched Deatte 5-byou de Battle, what is your opinion of it? It called my attention a while ago because a lot of advertisements for the anime appeared on my social medial accounts, and on the site I watch anime.
I like your profile picture, is it a character from an anime or manga maybe?
Evangelion is an amazing anime; I finished the Rebuild of Evangelion movies a while ago, and they were very unique and entertaining. Who is your favorite character from the anime?
I noticed you read Honomieru Shounen; it called my attention so I added it to my PTR list a while ago. I am aware it was axed, but I am still interested in hearing other's perspectives, how would you describe it?
What consols is it on?
Why how's the game compare?
It was the "what score you disagree with most" thread, don't take it too seriously :)