Carr0tCak3's Profile - MyAnimeList.net

Fantasy Anime League

Nobody needs to know who I am irl so I'm just gonna outline how I rate anime/manga:

Story:
Unnecessary plot points? Odd tangents? Plotholes? Does the story make
sense? Is it a unique story? (not needed, but extra points) And the big one:
Does it work for what it's trying to do?
Story has the largest impact on the overall score obviously.
Art
Very small impact on overall score, almost doesn't matter.
If I notice that the art is good, then it'll get above a 7, if unusually bad,
below 5, othewise, 6 or so.
Sound
Same as art, except harder to tell. As a musician, music that catches my ear or
fits the theme well will get an extra point or two.
Character
Second largest impact on overall score. Well-written characters are
rewarded the most. Chliché characters won't get points unless they are spoof within
a spoof show, or good despite, or while using, the cliché-ness. Also, were
there interesting and/or unique characters? This goes for protagonists,
antagonists, side characters, and extras.
Enjoyment
No impact. This is entirely my own opinion, this tells how much I enjoyed
this particular show. In this section, I usually explain why I like it, but
sometimes I won't be able to.
Overall
"Score" Number.
Primarily impacted by Story. I will try to be very strict with my scores.