Spice and Wolf (light novel)
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Haven't watched the original but this has a good feel to it, very calming to watch. Nice OP as well |
| Really bad. I don't know what happened to the chief director considering it is the exact same person who directed the original series, but it's a massive disappointment. Something terrible must be going on in production in comparison to when the original series aired, whether it is an industry or a studio/whatever problem I don't know but it's massively disappointing. |
 "Awoooo!" howled Holo. Fear gripped the men. Even Lawrence stepped back. Should they have seen her fangs, he had prepared a cover story: that all sufficiently angry women seemed to bear fangs. |
| I am satisfied, very good adaptation, more close to the light novel than the firs adaptation was. The first scene set the mood teasing a character from the spin-off light novel series, the background music was pretty good, the design of Holo is crisp and "sexy" as she should be and she still speaks that archaic oiran dailect (the dialect of high ranking japanese courtisans) that I loved so much. And the color palette!, man those skies looked beautiful! |
IshitatesoApr 2, 7:36 AM
 |
| Holo! Long time no see~ still as magnificent as ever, and I'm so happy that her voice and Lawrence's voice are still the same as the original version. Looking forward to Holo eating apples in almost every episode, hahaha. |
 |
| Haven't seen the original anime but I can already tell this gonna be a perfect replacement of Sousou no Frieren for me. Love the overall vibe. Great start, waiting for more. |
| I can't believe it. It's actually back. Nostalgia overwhelm me. |
| I’m so glad everyone is back! Especially Yarei, now they know they should follow the LN source more |
 |
| This was actually much better than I thought it'd be. Definitely gonna continue with the LN after the anime ends if the vibes are the same. |
❝Kabo-chan is ran by the MAL staff team and does not respond to individual comments made on her profile.❞ I was immensely devastated. |
| I don't understand why there is so much hate. The original adapted pretty fine in my opinion. It's just not possible to animate every single side story/monologue in a book. This first episode now invigorates my love for this series. And OMG that scene in the beginning |
Reply to booyah10
I don't understand why there is so much hate.
The original adapted pretty fine in my opinion. It's just not possible to animate every single side story/monologue in a book.
This first episode now invigorates my love for this series. And OMG that scene in the beginning
The original adapted pretty fine in my opinion. It's just not possible to animate every single side story/monologue in a book.
This first episode now invigorates my love for this series. And OMG that scene in the beginning
| @booyah10 Don't mind the crows. Even though I too was prepared for that the studio would pull some shitty, cheap nostalgia trip, but it has turned out to be actually a pretty good adaptation if we can judge that just from one episode. |
|
| I was surprised with this, when I find it on airing anime. Haven't seen any news about a reboot or probably just forget about it. I kind of forgot most of the details about this anime but not their first meeting. Glad I could watch this on HD. I still picture that cheese when he says his name. I don't really read LN so I'm not sure if that was their child or not and it seems they are in the north. |
| More like "Wolf and bad CGI" The art style and quality seem worse too, wtf? Sure, the lines are cleaner and there's higher resolution and gradient filters, but the stylization and backgrounds are really a step down... Was this reboot really frigging needed? |
| Lets gooo,the wise wolf is back!!! |
| I originally wanted to watch the original Spice & Wolf before watching the Remake... But since the Remake already came out, I guess I'll watch it first. Or I could watch the old version simultaneously with the new version and spot the difference. I heard some people doing the same thing with Urusei Yatsura so it could be interesting. I already saw some people bitching about the character design of the new anime and watching the first episode I didn't think it was bad at all. I actually liked them more than what I saw in the original design online. But then again, I may not have the nostalgia to think the original design is better. Anyway, this has a very interesting premise. Can't say I'm hooked just yet but I'm interested enough to continue watching it. The OP and ED are good and Holo looks like a fun character. So glad it's 25 consecutive episodes which is somewhat of a rarity these days. Hoping for a full adaptation! |
| Pretty calming OP. That was quite the crowd that Kraft saw in the field. Quite the being to find curled up in your cart. The wolf spirit given form huh. Looks like the bond between Kraft and the village is a deep one. Wheat possession sure sounds pretty useful. I guess being a god of harvest can also be exhausting as well given the balance needed between the village and the land. The bond between Holo and Kraft going forward sure looks to be an interesting one. Overall an excellent opening ep that featured a fine balance of lore, character intros and comedy via the interactions between Holo and Kraft. Never thought that one of Ami Koshimizu's greatest works gets a reboot but man she truly shines here. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
Reply to Narizor
I never watched the original version, so I decided to watch the remake. At first glance, for someone who knows nothing about the story, it seems like it will be something sad, especially with the opening scene of the tale, which I imagine is Holo narrating it.
The OP and the ED are pleasant to listen to, but the soundtrack is on another level, it enamored me and convinced me to watch this anime.
P.S.: Would you recommend watching the original version first, or should I wait until I finish the remake?
The OP and the ED are pleasant to listen to, but the soundtrack is on another level, it enamored me and convinced me to watch this anime.
P.S.: Would you recommend watching the original version first, or should I wait until I finish the remake?
| @Narizor I'd recommend watching them side by side, each episode as it comes out, starting with the 2024 version. So far, the 2024 is more faithful to the story... But looks kinda bad. |
| man chills all throughout the episode wtf this is such a W |
 |
Reply to Valkidol
Really bad. I don't know what happened to the chief director considering it is the exact same person who directed the original series, but it's a massive disappointment. Something terrible must be going on in production in comparison to when the original series aired, whether it is an industry or a studio/whatever problem I don't know but it's massively disappointing.
| @Valkidol what i don't get is how the hell after 20~ years of bad anime CGI, we still have bad anime CGI that's as horrid as ever... And yeah, feels like a really lazy reboot, the TWO things it has going for it is actually following the novel's story this time, and a face art style that's A LITTLE closer to the original illustrations (more rounded faces)... |
| I remember watching the first series back in 2008, almost at the same time I joined MAL, and this first episode brought back some nice memories. Also, I'm so glad they kept the same VA for the remake. Fukuyama Jun and Koshimizu Ami always had some great chemistry together. |
| This is going to be amazing. Koshimizu Ami's playful archaic Japanese is a treat to listen to. |
| Here's a couple screenshots comparing the moonlight scene with the original... |
| Loved the original and I expect I'm going to really like this one too. Same vibes, but looks a lot better for sure. That said I'd be lying if I didn't say that I would have prefered for them to make a sequel instead. |
| "Perhaps there is a universal, absolute truth. Perhaps it justifies every question. But that's beyond the reach of these small hands." Mamoru Oshii There is a cult of ignorance (...) nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” Isaac Asimov |
| I never got to watch the first adaptation or read the light novel but ofc I know it is well beloved, looking forward to the series. |
| Music line up is fantastic. Opening by Hana Hope. Ending by ClariS. OST by Keven Penkin. I never really saw Spice and Wolf as show for everyone though. Feel like some will be disappointed because it's not what they expected. Holo's super cute but I don't know if that alone will be enough. |
| Passione did such a great work with Higurashi art and animation. Why didn't they make this one at least as good as Higurashi was? I really hate the gradient shading. It looks extremely cheap. It's not like everything looks bad, but shading is really seriously downgrading the visual experience. Yeah it's surely cheaper to fill character's hair with gradient, but come on. I liked the old chara design more too. Too much of obvious 3DCG too. At least the animation itself is good when it's not 3D. Except visuals, there's nothing to complain about. Thanks God they got Koshimizu Ami as Holo again. I really can't imagine anyone else as her. Flawless performance. I'm really in love with her voice. |
rsc-plApr 2, 2:03 PM
| Dub = fake crap. Always. |
| Really solid first episode. So much nostalgia It kind of feels like we are Holo in that first scene. Telling the kids our story from long ago. |
| Been a while since I've watched a fairy tale-like story. Haven't seen the 1st adaptation. Might check it out after this. |
| "I will use my ball to make you remember." -- Haruka Kiyomine, 2024 |
Reply to riffenrun
Not upset nor impressed. But i hadn't actually expected much. I'm a huge fan of the original . This simply wasn't as good.
Heard arguments that it looks better or more modern. This just doesn't match the charm of the original visually or audibly.
Also heard how the original wasn't sufficiently true to the story. But i watch anime. I only rarely read the manga/light novels and then only after watching an anime that has especially pleased me. So i don't really care if its true to 'lore'.
At the risk of dating myself - this is just a mimeographed copy.
They would have been much better off continuing from where the original left off. I would have been delighted to have the story continued even if it wasn't quite as good.
But this is getting excited to unwrap a package only to find nothing inside. Just disappointment.
Bad plan.
Heard arguments that it looks better or more modern. This just doesn't match the charm of the original visually or audibly.
Also heard how the original wasn't sufficiently true to the story. But i watch anime. I only rarely read the manga/light novels and then only after watching an anime that has especially pleased me. So i don't really care if its true to 'lore'.
At the risk of dating myself - this is just a mimeographed copy.
They would have been much better off continuing from where the original left off. I would have been delighted to have the story continued even if it wasn't quite as good.
But this is getting excited to unwrap a package only to find nothing inside. Just disappointment.
Bad plan.
| @riffenrun I love the original seasons myself and own them on Blu-ray, but this is just your nostalgia talking. What you said basically sounds like you would have never liked a remake because it isn't the old show. The animation was actually more lively than the old show. The music is done by Kevin Penkin who is known by most as a genius. We have the same two voice actors and we even have the same director. There is so much love to the source material in this adaptation and while nothing can be perfect you really are dating yourself as you said. They even plan to go past where the original did so if it does well enough you will also be getting a sequel to the original in some ways. It was smarter to start from well the start as the og is 15 years old and a pure sequel would have attracted less people. Honestly simply comparing it to the original is close minded and missing the entire point of why the director wanted to make this adaptation. It is simply because he loves Spice and Wolf, and without him neither the original or this new one would exist. Spice and Wolf just isn't an easy adaptation hence why the original both had changes, and even skipped an entire book while also leaving on a cliff hanger on their relationship. This sequel is a chance to actually have the books adapted fully and I feel real fans of Spice and Wolf should be excited. |
 |
| I have never watched the original so I'm happy about this reboot. This look pretty interesting! |
| A great first episode that stays true to the tone and quality we expected of a remake of this show and one that follows more closely to the books so far. |
| Good first episode, I even watched the first episode of the original to compare and reminisce (having seen the original). His directing seemed a lot better in this remake, the episode seemed to flow a lot more naturally than the original first episode, not as many wacky camera shots either. Not that I remember the original having that problem, but it's something you notice when comparing like this. Obviously the remake is a lot vibrant and modern with it's visuals, even the watercolor backgrounds pop off the screen far more. I think I prefer the more moderate art of the original. |
GakutoDeathGlareApr 2, 6:51 PM
| I am in pure ecstasy!!!! Never thought an anime would make me smile during an entire episode. I'm just so happy this remake is happening that I can't put in words. It is clear that the ending animation in a reference to the first one of the original, and I loved it. Thanks I've born in time to watch such masterpiece. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Ookami to Koushinryou: Merchant Meets the Wise Wolf Episode 7 DiscussionStark700 - May 13 |
49 |
by HotRodster
»»
16 minutes ago |
|
» Did any of you know J.Michael Tatum has narrated The audio book for the spice and wolf light novel?APolygons2 - 4 hours ago |
5 |
by Eva_Unit_00
»»
28 minutes ago |
|
» How does this compare to the original?anizawa89 - May 10 |
27 |
by bvajen2
»»
5 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Ookami to Koushinryou: Merchant Meets the Wise Wolf Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 )Softhenic03 - Apr 29 |
91 |
by CartoonVelocirap
»»
10 hours ago |
|
Poll: » Ookami to Koushinryou: Merchant Meets the Wise Wolf Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - May 6 |
112 |
by Treyv0n
»»
Yesterday, 2:42 PM |