| So after 8 ep rewrite is already at a 7.00, where do you guys think it will end off with after it finishes airing? Giving reasons to support your claim My guess is around 6.85 because i would assume the ending won't drop the score too much |
| 8bit's Rewrite is a rushed, unnecessary project without any value for anyone with a bit of common sense (or a good taste). BUT! Fanboys are strong with this one, so... probably too high (the final score of course). |
| Ratings can change alot after an anime finishes like Grisaia no Kajitsu which was under 7 while airing then somehow ended up at 7.66 after it finished |
| Ok if this was actually animated properly this would be minimum 8.5 and thats not overrated since its that great and could be at a 9 rated if they went over the top but with this adaptation it could either be a 6.9 or a 7.05 which is shocking to see how bad they adapted (imo i dont think its garbage but the community wont really look at it after seeing the rating so low) Blane Tensho |
 |
Yourlolm said: Ok if this was actually animated properly this would be minimum 8.5 and thats not overrated since its that great and could be at a 9 rated if they went over the top but with this adaptation it could either be a 6.9 or a 7.05 which is shocking to see how bad they adapted (imo i dont think its garbage but the community wont really look at it after seeing the rating so low) Blame Tensho Blame Aniplex too. And Key. And Tanaka. |
| Key honestly just made a terrible idea to let 8bit adapt the VN |
Rin_Kitsune said: Key honestly just made a terrible idea to let 8bit adapt the VN Yes that it true but you also got to blame Tensho for his terrible directing, even if the animation usnt great it still could be a lot better if it was a different director |
| |
Yourlolm said: Rin_Kitsune said: Key honestly just made a terrible idea to let 8bit adapt the VN Yes that it true but you also got to blame Tensho for his terrible directing, even if the animation usnt great it still could be a lot better if it was a different director at least they kept the same music from the Visual Novel It's sad to see Rewrite this low. If Kyoto, or JC did this instead of 8bit, it could EASILY have a 8.60 score. And if they adapted it 100% perfectly with two 24 episode seasons, then it would be a 8.80+ |
 |
| Well maybe they will eventually do a remake of this trainwreck |
DoctorWasabi said: Yourlolm said: Yes that it true but you also got to blame Tensho for his terrible directing, even if the animation usnt great it still could be a lot better if it was a different director at least they kept the same music from the Visual Novel It's sad to see Rewrite this low. If Kyoto, or JC did this instead of 8bit, it could EASILY have a 8.60 score. And if they adapted it 100% perfectly with two 24 episode seasons, then it would be a 8.80+ Rin_Kitsune said: Well maybe they will eventually do a remake of this trainwreck To be a good adaptation, it would need two 24 ep seasons and then 13 eps for Moon and Terra at least. So that's a BIG no for any remake. |
| What you just said was what i meant when i said for a remake... Pref: 24-26 ep main routes 12-13 ep moon+terra no need for 3 seasons |
Rin_Kitsune said: What you just said was what i meant when i said for a remake... Pref: 24-26 ep main routes 12-13 ep moon+terra no need for 3 seasons What's the difference? No one's gonna touch Rewrite again (or anything Key related) after this garbage. |
Gotrys_Cheslock said: Rin_Kitsune said: What you just said was what i meant when i said for a remake... Pref: 24-26 ep main routes 12-13 ep moon+terra no need for 3 seasons What's the difference? No one's gonna touch Rewrite again (or anything Key related) after this garbage. hay this is real good stuff mate. I like wherel this was going. |
UnknownDepthAug 24, 2016 3:24 PM
Gotrys_Cheslock said: Rin_Kitsune said: What you just said was what i meant when i said for a remake... Pref: 24-26 ep main routes 12-13 ep moon+terra no need for 3 seasons What's the difference? No one's gonna touch Rewrite again (or anything Key related) after this garbage. You really think that anything Key makes next wont get another adaptation? Thats bs. 1. Key is still making Visual novels Eg Harmonia and are still one of the biggest VN studios out there, whats not to say a studio would be interested in adapting more of their work in the future 2. Just because an adaptation wasn't great doesn't mean the Developers won't be able to get another anime adaptation, you see many other unsuccessful studios carry on getting adaptations so Key (Well known for VN success) can get more if they want more, it takes one studio to get an adaptation and Key are well known with studios such as Kyoani JC staff and P.A Works even parts with white fox Etc. 3. You are forgetting many adaptations are different from the actual source material, they follow it but anything that is animated may always miss out a few scenes or can change completely, all of Keys visual novels never dissapoint so you cant blame them completely for rewrites failure as they only gave the ok and Aniplex is the one who ruined the adaptation as there wasnt enough time for the adaptation, only recently it was announced and they were only given a low budget to deal with so obviously its not going to be great but it takes time to make a great anime and this had none, if this aired a year or 2 later it probably would gave been a success but sadly it had no time to be made a masterpiece, they had to get it out on time. BDs can be better art wise but nothing else could really change much which is the case in most BDs. You cant blame a VN studio if the adaptation was made poorly, if the VN sucked it wouldn't be a surprise but if it was supposed to be very good the only thing you can blame the studio for is giving the ok and even then they do it for the money and they deserve it if they are making masterpieces. Only blame the studio for the Ok but you cant blame them any more it was poorly adapted. *End of Rant* Btw theres always a possibility for a remake as long as a studio is interested in it and Key has got a remake before E.g Kanon, its unlikely but the possibility is still there. |
| |
Yourlolm said: Gotrys_Cheslock said: What's the difference? No one's gonna touch Rewrite again (or anything Key related) after this garbage. You really think that anything Key makes next wont get another adaptation? Thats bs. 1. Key is still making Visual novels Eg Harmonia and are still one of the biggest VN studios out there, whats not to say a studio would be interested in adapting more of their work in the future 2. Just because an adaptation wasn't great doesn't mean the Developers won't be able to get another anime adaptation, you see many other unsuccessful studios carry on getting adaptations so Key (Well known for VN success) can get more if they want more, it takes one studio to get an adaptation and Key are well known with studios such as Kyoani JC staff and P.A Works even parts with white fox Etc. 3. You are forgetting many adaptations are different from the actual source material, they follow it but anything that is animated may always miss out a few scenes or can change completely, all of Keys visual novels never dissapoint so you cant blame them completely for rewrites failure as they only gave the ok and Aniplex is the one who ruined the adaptation as there wasnt enough time for the adaptation, only recently it was announced and they were only given a low budget to deal with so obviously its not going to be great but it takes time to make a great anime and this had none, if this aired a year or 2 later it probably would gave been a success but sadly it had no time to be made a masterpiece, they had to get it out on time. BDs can be better art wise but nothing else could really change much which is the case in most BDs. You cant blame a VN studio if the adaptation was made poorly, if the VN sucked it wouldn't be a surprise but if it was supposed to be very good the only thing you can blame the studio for is giving the ok and even then they do it for the money and they deserve it if they are making masterpieces. Only blame the studio for the Ok but you cant blame them any more it was poorly adapted. *End of Rant* Btw theres always a possibility for a remake as long as a studio is interested in it and Key has got a remake before E.g Kanon, its unlikely but the possibility is still there. Oh really? You mean another 13 eps "adaptation"? No one's gonna touch this stuff. No one wanted Rewrite after this amazingly generous offer from Aniplex, so they gave it to 1bit... 8bit. Also, I'm not forgetting anything. VN adaptations are always different from the original source, but Rewrite is butchered beyond belief! What was the point in making this thing? What were they even thinking with this piece of shit... And cheapskates from Aniplex are deluding themselves that this joke is gonna sell? Seriously, what the hell... |
N7n4shiSep 12, 2016 4:35 AM
Gotrys_Cheslock said: Yourlolm said: You really think that anything Key makes next wont get another adaptation? Thats bs. 1. Key is still making Visual novels Eg Harmonia and are still one of the biggest VN studios out there, whats not to say a studio would be interested in adapting more of their work in the future 2. Just because an adaptation wasn't great doesn't mean the Developers won't be able to get another anime adaptation, you see many other unsuccessful studios carry on getting adaptations so Key (Well known for VN success) can get more if they want more, it takes one studio to get an adaptation and Key are well known with studios such as Kyoani JC staff and P.A Works even parts with white fox Etc. 3. You are forgetting many adaptations are different from the actual source material, they follow it but anything that is animated may always miss out a few scenes or can change completely, all of Keys visual novels never dissapoint so you cant blame them completely for rewrites failure as they only gave the ok and Aniplex is the one who ruined the adaptation as there wasnt enough time for the adaptation, only recently it was announced and they were only given a low budget to deal with so obviously its not going to be great but it takes time to make a great anime and this had none, if this aired a year or 2 later it probably would gave been a success but sadly it had no time to be made a masterpiece, they had to get it out on time. BDs can be better art wise but nothing else could really change much which is the case in most BDs. You cant blame a VN studio if the adaptation was made poorly, if the VN sucked it wouldn't be a surprise but if it was supposed to be very good the only thing you can blame the studio for is giving the ok and even then they do it for the money and they deserve it if they are making masterpieces. Only blame the studio for the Ok but you cant blame them any more it was poorly adapted. *End of Rant* Btw theres always a possibility for a remake as long as a studio is interested in it and Key has got a remake before E.g Kanon, its unlikely but the possibility is still there. Oh really? You mean another 13 eps "adaptation"? No one's gonna touch this stuff. No one wanted Rewrite after this amazingly generous offer from Aniplex, so they gave it to 1bit... 8bit. Also, I'm not forgetting anything. VN adaptations are always different from the original source, but Rewrite is butchered beyond belief! What was the point in making this thing? What were they even thinking with piece of shit... And cheapskates from Aniplex are deluding themselves that this joke is gonna sell? Seriously, what the hell... Have you seem Tokyo Ghoul. Go see it and then read the manga. Then come back n talk about butchered beyond belief. |
| Lots of the low ratings come from people who dropped it at early episodes, so odds are their votes won't be counted in due to the 1/5th rule, so I'll say somewhere in the 6.6-7.2 range. |
 |
| It's already at a 6.99, that says a lot. If this wasn't a Key anime I would've dropped this ages ago... |
| I think this anime is going to be left in the dust, like most unmemorable(not saying it is) seasonal anime. It will probably stay around 6.90 or 6.96, maybe higher after the blu ray release. |
 |
Yourlolm said: Rin_Kitsune said: Key honestly just made a terrible idea to let 8bit adapt the VN Yes that it true but you also got to blame Tensho for his terrible directing, even if the animation usnt great it still could be a lot better if it was a different director agreed, pfft letting the guy who directed grisaia no kajitsu direct rewrite was a terrrible idea. Does 8bit even have any good directors? |
| It's probably going to drop to about 6.90 with how salty these forums are. |
 |
sat2400 said: I expect 8-bits make second season I expect nothing. And I hope I'm right. |
| Rewrite has a lot of fanboys(me being one of them who rate this a 10/10), but honestly idk. 7.1 wouldn't be that bad |
In the name of Allah, the Gracious, the Merciful. | You know what I hate the most? People who aren't free. They're no more than cattle. |
| From looks the things now the final avg most likely 6.50-6.75 since after episode 12 aired it went from 6.93 to 6.86 plus the people that drop or have their episodes while watching early on (episodes 1-6) doesn't count. |
LightBladeNova said: It makes me sad to know that still hardly anyone knows what a visual novel is, even in the anime community. |
| I don't care anymore, it's not Rewrite. |
| Hopefully 6.50 but even that is too high |
jc9622 said: DoctorWasabi said: I agree, Kyoto Animation or J.C Staff would have handled this adaption a lot better than how 8bit is handling this adaptation. Though, J.C Staff did rush the 1st Season of Little Busters so they would have probably done the same thing for the 1st Season of Rewrite. at least they kept the same music from the Visual Novel It's sad to see Rewrite this low. If Kyoto, or JC did this instead of 8bit, it could EASILY have a 8.60 score. And if they adapted it 100% perfectly with two 24 episode seasons, then it would be a 8.80+ Since Kyoto Animation no longer adapts Key's VN, J.C Staff is our only hope for another good KEY anime adaptation. Little Busters Refrain was absolutely beautiful though. No other studio is ever gonna touch Rewrite again for a future remake of the entire thing, considering how badly 8bit is fucking over the show. It's really sad because I've put 40+ hours into the VN and I experienced so many emotions in that time. It's like seeing your baby die :( |
|
DoctorWasabi said: jc9622 said: I agree, Kyoto Animation or J.C Staff would have handled this adaption a lot better than how 8bit is handling this adaptation. Though, J.C Staff did rush the 1st Season of Little Busters so they would have probably done the same thing for the 1st Season of Rewrite. Since Kyoto Animation no longer adapts Key's VN, J.C Staff is our only hope for another good KEY anime adaptation. Little Busters Refrain was absolutely beautiful though. QFT! No other studio is ever gonna touch Rewrite again for a future remake of the entire thing, considering how badly 8bit is fucking over the show. Unfortunately. It's really sad because I've put 40+ hours into the VN and I experienced so many emotions in that time. It's like seeing your baby die :( It's 250+ hours in my case, but again, I agree. |
Gotrys_Cheslock said: DoctorWasabi said: Little Busters Refrain was absolutely beautiful though. QFT! No other studio is ever gonna touch Rewrite again for a future remake of the entire thing, considering how badly 8bit is fucking over the show. Unfortunately. It's really sad because I've put 40+ hours into the VN and I experienced so many emotions in that time. It's like seeing your baby die :( It's 250+ hours in my case, but again, I agree. 250 hours? what O__O ? The common route is long, but Idk how you clocked in 250+ . The database says it takes around 50 hours to complete https://vndb.org/v751 Unless you replayed the VN |
|
| This anime will probably end with the same score of Masou Gakuen or Hundred from last season. I'm not sure how did they manage to screw up. Key adaptation is easy money in Japan. Just give the budget and get the profit later. |
DoctorWasabi said: 250 hours? what O__O ? The common route is long, but Idk how you clocked in 250+ . The database says it takes around 50 hours to complete https://vndb.org/v751 Unless you replayed the VN Well... Common route + Kotori Common route + Chihaya Common route + Lucia Common route + Shizuru Common route + Akane Moon Terra "Spoiled end" quest Common route (again) for Kotori's seed planting quest + some friends Common route (AGAIN!) for the rest of the quests & friends + Oppai ending (3 scenes =/= a route) All this without a walkthrough. And no skipping of course. |
DoctorWasabi said: 250 hours? what O__O ? The common route is long, but Idk how you clocked in 250+ . The database says it takes around 50 hours to complete https://vndb.org/v751 Unless you replayed the VN " > 50 " = " 50hs+++++ " But really, 250 is ... even completing all quests and replaying common route, seems too much. |
Arikado-Sep 22, 2016 10:21 AM
Arikado- said: DoctorWasabi said: 250 hours? what O__O ? The common route is long, but Idk how you clocked in 250+ . The database says it takes around 50 hours to complete https://vndb.org/v751 Unless you replayed the VN " > 50 " = " 50hs+++++ " But really, 250 is ... even completing all quests and replaying common route, seems too much. I have completed all of the girls routes in 43 hours, and only have Moon and Terra left to do. I would assume it would take me to alittle above 50 hours ( which is why I said around 50 hours ) |
|
| Why everyone so convinced that score rises after anime end? There is a possibility that score drops even more, if majority rate it 6 or less, because last episodes are most important for *MAL e-peen anime score* ...and those 10/11/12 episodes were bad.. |
| -3000 votes equals + 0.7 in score. |
N7n4shiSep 23, 2016 12:54 PM
Nemeios said: For the guys who say J.C Staff is our only hope for another good KEY anime adaptation. Little busters is BY FAR the worst adaptation of key Rewrite at least don't try to adapt the VN and make plotholes and stupid changes from the original source Rewrite is an original route made from Tanaka, and now we will have moon and terra A LOT better than the bullshit that was Little busters Never forget Rin2 ending in 3 min without any dialogue :) . This post is lol worthy. "ORIGINAL ROUTE!!!! from MUH TANAKA" Get out of here! |
| The anime deserve 7+ because it got more serious I will probably end up rating it 7 The anime remind of Grisaia no Kajitsu, were it has weak start but got a lot better in last few episodes and the sequel was much better |
Nemeios said: I'm not even a fan from Tanaka, but is better to have an original route from te original author than what JC Staff did with LB!. Original route my ass. It's a fuckin' patchwork, not original route. LB anime fucked Komari and Haruka routes and the pacing of the first season was all over the place, but it was GODLY compared to this "original route" bullshit. And Refrain was simply amazing. Rin2 ending in that form was enough for me. In the VN it was all about Riki's fishing and Rin collecting cats, nothing really spectacular. Oh, and Hanabi is a beautiful song, so your Rin2 argument can go fuck itself. |
Gotrys_Cheslock said: Rin_Kitsune said: What you just said was what i meant when i said for a remake... Pref: 24-26 ep main routes 12-13 ep moon+terra no need for 3 seasons What's the difference? No one's gonna touch Rewrite again (or anything Key related) after this garbage. After the recent news..How wrong u were xD |
| "You can't spell slaughter without laughter". |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Rewrite Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Sep 24, 2016 |
294 |
by AyanoKiru
»»
May 25, 6:38 AM |
|
Poll: » Rewrite Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Aug 20, 2016 |
167 |
by AyanoKiru
»»
May 25, 5:28 AM |
|
Poll: » Rewrite Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jul 9, 2016 |
329 |
by AyanoKiru
»»
May 25, 4:12 AM |
|
Poll: » Rewrite Episode 7 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Aug 13, 2016 |
177 |
by Miki42
»»
Jan 10, 9:41 AM |
|
Poll: » Rewrite Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Sep 10, 2016 |
112 |
by White_Alice
»»
Dec 15, 2023 11:46 PM |