Am I the only one...?

komic said:
it works for anime only viewer as well as they won't have to wait for the next series.

Mich666 said:
I still don't get it why you don't understand the fact that "sol loli yuri fanservice" is main marketing point of this show. It's sells and that's the reason there is abundance of it, people are simply expecting it.

I honestly doubt they won't include any of it in upcoming season 4 even if they have to bend the story.
People need to finally understand that anime and manga mediums are different and what works pretty well there doesn't have to necessarilly work here.

Don't make this adaptation into something it isn't. It's not like there is any deep plot going on anyway.

CookingPriest said:
Please do try to explain what this adaptation and story is, since you apparently claim to know better than the mangaka, who very clearly steered story in the opposite direction from what you want it to be.

Mich666 said:

This is something I already did in the previous episode thread. I'm saying here that anime and manga of Prillya are fundamentally different, manga is targetted solely at T-M fans while the anime demographics is made of fans of sol, lolis and yuri (with small but vocal group of T-M fans) and Silver Link is doing the show with that in mind.

And as for whole Prillya - it was and always will be lighthearted show that can be considered fanservice/reference spin-off based on more serious original. And it's good enough for what it does. But it would be certainly foolish to think it's more than that as no copy can surpass its original (well..).

And as for whole Prillya - it was and always will be lighthearted show that can be considered fanservice/reference spin-off based on more serious original.

CookingPriest said:

And yet somehow it is completely faithful adaptation. Hmm, strange.
ALso no, it is targeted at TM fans. They would not bother recreating certain things from VN otherwise.


Again no.
I am going to assume you have not read the VN and know nothing about the franchise or you would know that Prillya is pretty much the same in terms of tone as the original. And in terms of structure it is identical to the VN.

This bit was especially funny:

Considering, you know, entire second half of first season , entire second half of 2wei, entirety of 3rei.

Also it is factually not a spin off.


Maybe I should now go around claiming that since first four or so days of fate route is pretty much SOL adventures, FSN has no right to do anything serious because OBVIOUSLY it is lighthearted.

WrongPriest said:
> Implying TM fans are not lolicons

MightyM16 said:


some of them are both, some are either one or the other

If you are both, then you get the best of both worlds in the Prisma anime

WrongPriest said:


But the manga's just as bad lel

Or at least much of a muchness

MightyM16 said:
Prillya is not a spin off? How come?

mangamuscle said:


Because Nasu has acknowledged Prisma Illya as the 4th route (Illya's route) in Fate/Stay Night, so if you call it a spin-off you must also label UBW and Heaven's Feel as spin-offs.

MightyM16 said:


Prillya, the Illya route?

pls
That was a joke

mangamuscle said:


Then the joke is on you:

http://tsukikan.com/misc/kinoko-and-takashi-q-a-fate-stay-night-unlimited-blade-works.html

mangamuscle said:


Then the joke is on you:

http://tsukikan.com/misc/kinoko-and-takashi-q-a-fate-stay-night-unlimited-blade-works.html

Insertanamehere said:
That was in fact still a joke, so I don't know why you're using it as a statement of fact.

laidellent said:
Uh no,that was a joke

mangamuscle said:




So just because you disagree with Nasu you call it a joke? This is not an rpg where you can say "I attempt to disbelieve" to negate an illusion.

MightyM16 said:


No, it was a joke.
Nasu was only kidding when he said Prillya is the Illya route he couldn't make

It's not a question of disagreeing, it's a question of you not understanding it was a joke and thinking Nasu actually considers Prisma as the "real deal" Illya route

astroprogs said:
To be fair, the interview is filled with serious answers mixed in with joke answers (rocket launcher Gandr lol).
On the other hand, sentences like "Of course. Someone was bound to finish what I can't do myself. Humans are amazing beings!" just reinforces that he was joking.

Insertanamehere said:
An actual Illya route would be one that diverges from within the events of Fate/Stay Night. Kaleid Liner doesn't, so it is not an actual Illya route.

Insertanamehere said:
well you see
thats the definition of a route bruv

Insertanamehere said:
well you see
thats the definition of a route bruv

mangamuscle said:


To me it looks you people are in complete denial, delusionally thinking Nasu (or someone else at Type Moon) will make an Illya route, therefore this must be a joke -_-;

Since no matter how I look at it, we both read the same text and it is clearly not a joke.

mangamuscle said:


Your definition is artificial, you will not find it in any book. The only thing that prevents this being translated into a visual novel is that the manga is not over (and will probably will not for years to come).

CookingPriest said:

So it is not route of FSN.

But it is a route of fate branch, just like Apo technically is "Jeanne Route".

MightyM16 said:
It is a joke, it's just that something is making you unable to perceive the fact that Nasu was only kidding specially because as you see, most other people here recognize the fact that it was a joke :V

Prillya is a spin off, idk if you consider
it canon or not ( I don't) but it's not Illya's route not now not ever

And even if Prillya was canon it's not the Illya route just because of it's focus on Illya or whatever, that's like saying Type moon april fools 2013 is Sacchin route

mangamuscle said:


The "one million people here cannot be wrong" argument, priceless, as people minds had magical powers that restructured reality depending on the number that denied facts.

I see you hard at work denying reality.

Apples and oranges, all I am saying is that Nasu meant what he said (whether he did not want or lacked the drive to make a 4th route is anyone's guess), nothing more, nothing less.

mangamuscle said:


Your definition is artificial, you will not find it in any book. The only thing that prevents this being translated into a visual novel is that the manga is not over (and will probably will not for years to come).

mangamuscle said:

Apples and oranges, all I am saying is that Nasu meant what he said (whether he did not want or lacked the drive to make a 4th route is anyone's guess), nothing more, nothing less.

Insertanamehere said:

And Hiroyama said otherwise, but I've yet to see you mention that.

MightyM16 said:
And apparently only you know what's the truth, if that's not being conceited I don't know what else is

I see yours in trying to keep up with your disillusion

And on what basis you say that? Me and multiple other users here identified he was joking because of what he said and the way he addressed the statement

It's also known that Illya route was united with Sakura route and became part of Heaven's Feel

mangamuscle said:


Usually a person knowing the truth while a bunch called him names is called a visionary :p



Whoa, you are projecting your own feelings HARD.



It is a known fact that Nasu's route for Illya route was unfinished and merged into Sakura's route. Yet knowing that fact, years later some people still call for (another) route for Illya. Matter of fact they are praying for a (non magical girl) Illya route and shooting down anyone that says otherwise. If down the line Type Moon decides to milk the franchise (and hire some other writer, since Nasu would have already wrote it if he really wanted) and do another Illya route, I lose nothing, I might even be entertained if they make it into a TV series or OVA. But if years later the only Illya route still is Prisma, said fans will be disillusioned (or even heart broken).

.

So, the longer you evade reality, the harder it will hit you

MightyM16 said:
4- I could care less about an Illya route, not a fan of lolis as love interests

CookingPriest said:

> Nasu says something
"Oh its totes a joke"
> KALMIA is being humble and makes a joke
"HE TOTALLY WAS SERIOUS ANd MEANT WHAT HE SAID"
Dat consistency.

mangamuscle said:

The nile so vast, as to be ever present.