| Sure, it's the worst one imo, but still the one with the best romance and the one that portrays Saber the best. Fuck Fate Shirou though. |
black1blade said: Zulkir said: As someone who a) Watched DEEN F/sn after reading the F/sn VN b) Watched DEEN Higurashi after reading the Higurashi VN I can confidently state that DEEN F/sn >>> DEEN Higurashi DEEN Higurashi is such an unspeakable disaster compared to the VN, that DEEN F/sn looks like a faithful adaptation with a slight abuse of original content. I am yet to read the Umineko VN, but I will probably ignore the DEEN version even after I read it. Well shit, I loved the higurashi anime. I need to get reading it seems. The higurashi OP is awesome though. |
 Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| Yep. Higurashi Redrawn VN (PS2 ver) >>>>> DEEN Higurashi anime. It makes even DEEN F/sn pretty much decent in comparison aside of characterizations. And forget DEEN Umineko. It doesn't exist for VN readers. |
| Rather not have anything else ruined by ufodeen. RIP in peace HF. |
antonn said: Rather not have anything else ruined by ufodeen. RIP in peace HF. Based Miura will guide us and also put many 'Zero references' I'm sure |
 |
ProphecyPriest said: Yep. Higurashi Redrawn VN (PS2 ver) >>>>> DEEN Higurashi anime. It makes even DEEN F/sn pretty much decent in comparison aside of characterizations. And forget DEEN Umineko. It doesn't exist for VN readers. I read the original (not redrawn) version, and I like it better. You get used to the art style during the first several scenes, and after that it only helps. Especially when there should be a the friendly/angry contrast in the scenes like Onikakushi-hen spoiler: But DEEN Higurashi is still no more than an emotionless sequence of VN spoilers. F/sn was treated much better. |
ZulkirJun 9, 2015 1:52 AM
Grey-Zone said: Maybe next time I should say I was joking. I thought that was obvious. Higurashi and Umineko got shitty adaptations, but that didn't surprise me.CapsuleCore said: Aww, I think we should give DEEN another chance. Wasn't the first season a complete flop though? AFAIK it was commercially one of DEENs worst projects, not sure if that info is correct though, but if it is then the chances for a season 2 are very low, considering they even went back to higurashi while leaving umineko in the dust for years. Also seriously, they had the worst music direction possible. I mean... COME ON! Using the OST "Core" (not related to you) for one of the two awesome Battler moments in the first half of the whole story, instead of using Tsubasa (instrumental) or something with equivalent awesomeness in that scene made it completely disappointing, I would have even prefered no music at all to be honest. And then dreamenddischarger replaced by Golden Slaughterer? How could they do it... Not to mention as good as every remix version was by FAR worse than their original counterpart... |
| Wait, you can joke? Woa. For some reason you always emitted the aura of a always serious database despite your avatar. Damn, appearances can be deceiving, double. |
 |
nocorras said: antonn said: Rather not have anything else ruined by ufodeen. RIP in peace HF. Based Miura will guide us and also put many 'Zero references' I'm sure Since there's not enough content he is sure to expand it. |
 |
Grey-Zone said: Wait, you can joke? Woa. For some reason you always emitted the aura of a always serious database despite your avatar. Damn, appearances can be deceiving, double. ^Me knows the feels. |
The sun is a deadly laser |
Zulkir said: Grey-Zone said: DEEN Umineko > DEEN F/sn At least I didn't drop it at ep3 like DEEN's F/sn and was actually looking forward to the next episodes, because I am quite the mystery (as in criminal investigation, not the "something mysterious" kind) fan. Although... yea what am I saying? The only VN that DEEN ever adapted was higurashi... and that would possibly become undone too if I finally got to read the VN version... As someone who a) Watched DEEN F/sn after reading the F/sn VN b) Watched DEEN Higurashi after reading the Higurashi VN I can confidently state that DEEN F/sn >>> DEEN Higurashi DEEN Higurashi is such an unspeakable disaster compared to the VN, that DEEN F/sn looks like a faithful adaptation with a slight abuse of original content. I am yet to read the Umineko VN, but I will probably ignore the DEEN version even after I read it. Wow seriously? I quite liked DEEN Higurashi Is the VN really that much better and different? |
| Only if I get Saber h-scenes. Otherwise it's a waste of my time. |
| Flip flapp flip flop flipp flapping flip flap |
invisibleink said: we just got mutant hulk gamma jizz dolhpins, if they do fate your ass is gettin mana dragonOnly if I get Saber h-scenes. Otherwise it's a waste of my time. |
Maloghurst said: invisibleink said: we just got mutant hulk gamma jizz dolhpins, if they do fate your ass is gettin mana dragonOnly if I get Saber h-scenes. Otherwise it's a waste of my time. They'll be creamin themselves over how much cgi they can put into that episode. |
MightyM16 said: Zulkir said: As someone who a) Watched DEEN F/sn after reading the F/sn VN b) Watched DEEN Higurashi after reading the Higurashi VN I can confidently state that DEEN F/sn >>> DEEN Higurashi DEEN Higurashi is such an unspeakable disaster compared to the VN, that DEEN F/sn looks like a faithful adaptation with a slight abuse of original content. I am yet to read the Umineko VN, but I will probably ignore the DEEN version even after I read it. Wow seriously? I quite liked DEEN Higurashi Is the VN really that much better and different? To be more exact, DEEN Higurashi is just a sequence of major spoilers of the VN. With EVERYTHING ELSE omitted. - Atmosphere (which actually makes the VN a masterpiece) - Character development (which actually makes the reader care for them) - 90% of the plot (everything related to the atmosphere and character development) Of course, it is impossible to fit the VN that is (or at least seemed to me) 2 times longer than the whole F/sn into the 48-episode anime. But they didn't even try. |
ZulkirJun 10, 2015 2:56 AM
antonn said: Maloghurst said: we just got mutant hulk gamma jizz dolhpins, if they do fate your ass is gettin mana dragon They'll be creamin themselves over how much cgi they can put into that episode. That actually looks pretty cool, I like the last shot with all the circuits Is that fan-art or more RN stuff I haven't seen? |
 |
WrongPriest said: antonn said: They'll be creamin themselves over how much cgi they can put into that episode. That actually looks pretty cool, I like the last shot with all the circuits Is that fan-art or more RN stuff I haven't seen? RN replacement. |
| I'm not even mad, I might put some time aside to go through the later RN version. That way I'll know what to expect for HF. |
|
WrongPriest said: I'm not even mad, I might put some time aside to go through the later RN version. That way I'll know what to expect for HF. HF has the lamest fucking replacement though. Yeah. |
|
Insertanamehere said: |
SaintEmiya said: Insertanamehere said: |
|
WrongPriest said: SaintEmiya said: Oh I was just responding to that one thing, I'm not getting involved completely in ANOTHER argument on ANOTHER thread. I'm feeling worn out :(. |
SaintEmiya said: Oh I was just responding to that one thing, I'm not getting involved completely in ANOTHER argument on ANOTHER thread. I'm feeling worn out :(. Ikr, this afternoon's been a doozey. |
|
CookingPriest said: WrongPriest said: I'm not even mad, I might put some time aside to go through the later RN version. That way I'll know what to expect for HF. HF has the lamest fucking replacement though. Yeah. In my honest opinion Sakura's reason for |
ProphecyPriest said: CookingPriest said: HF has the lamest fucking replacement though. Yeah. In my honest opinion Sakura's reason for Yes, that's what censoring does. |
Zulkir said: MightyM16 said: Wow seriously? I quite liked DEEN Higurashi Is the VN really that much better and different? To be more exact, DEEN Higurashi is just a sequence of major spoilers of the VN. With EVERYTHING ELSE omitted. - Atmosphere (which actually makes the VN a masterpiece) - Character development (which actually makes the reader care for them) - 90% of the plot (everything related to the atmosphere and character development) Of course, it is impossible to fit the VN that is (or at least seemed to me) 2 times longer than the whole F/sn into the 48-episode anime. But they didn't even try. wow, it seems ike I lost so much And I genuinely like Higurashi adaptation more than Fate/DEEN I guess I will have to read the VN now XD Insertanamehere said: ProphecyPriest said: In my honest opinion Sakura's reason for Yes, that's what censoring does. HF is pretty much the only route where the original is superior and makes more sense than the RN version |
MightyM16 said: HF is pretty much the only route where the original is superior and makes more sense than the RN version It's not, tho. As dum and clumsy and bad at decision making as Rin is, giving away one's magic crest is tantamount to giving away ones magecraft. :/ And Shirou gives away part of his circuit in Fate, which is also tantamount to giving away his magecraft. |
The sun is a deadly laser |
Forgetfulness said: Fate RN first h-alt.mira-nyan said: Maybe it's just cause it's like 3AM here but when did he do that?It's not, tho. As dum and clumsy and bad at decision making as Rin is, giving away one's magic crest is tantamount to giving away ones magecraft. :/ And Shirou gives away part of his circuit in Fate, which is also tantamount to giving away his magecraft. |
| I wish that anything Type Moon related should be handled by Ufotable in the future ... just so I can hear even more drama and salt going on throughout anime related forums,its funny and pathetic at the same time. |
Forgetfulness said: Well... did you watch the DEENime? Same thing happened. mira was talking about h-alts in Realta Nua and specifically mentions Fate, so, you know...CapsuleCore said: Never mind, I've never read that. Fate RN first h-alt. For a second there I thought I was being really stupid. |
amateur said: I wish that anything Type Moon related should be handled by Ufotable in the future ... just so I can hear even more drama and salt going on throughout anime related forums,its funny and pathetic at the same time. How would that be? Everything Type-moonXUfotable up to this point has been great. |
|
WrongPriest said: amateur said: I wish that anything Type Moon related should be handled by Ufotable in the future ... just so I can hear even more drama and salt going on throughout anime related forums,its funny and pathetic at the same time. How would that be? Everything Type-moonXUfotable up to this point has been great. I agree, and that includes the effect it's had on this forum. |
   |
ZeroDragon said: I agree, and that includes the effect it's had on this forum. That's the best thing they made happen, King of Heroes. |
WrongPriest said: How would that be? Everything Type-moonXUfotable up to this point has been great. lol |
mira-nyan said: MightyM16 said: HF is pretty much the only route where the original is superior and makes more sense than the RN version It's not, tho. As dum and clumsy and bad at decision making as Rin is, giving away one's magic crest is tantamount to giving away ones magecraft. :/ And Shirou gives away part of his circuit in Fate, which is also tantamount to giving away his magecraft. For the Fate route I'd argue that there were more good changes in the RN version than bad changes Not only some...questionable dialogue was changed but also new scenes were added to better flesh out the story I don't think that he "gave out " his circuit and is therefore unable to do magecraft anymore , I mean just after the event in the shack he traces his first sword About the UBW RN well, I seriously don't see that much of a problem in Rin giving up her crest as I believe a talented mage such as her would be able to overcome such downgrade easily |
MightyM16 said: I don't think that he "gave out " his circuit and is therefore unable to do magecraft anymore , I mean just after the event in the shack he traces his first sword He lost a few of his circuits he claimed that "he doesn't really use". From this, you can assume that Fate Shirou won't be able to have all 27 magic circuits functional ever in his life as opposed the other two (which actually have activated all 27 DURING the grail war). Fate Shirou barely used any of his magic circuits in the entirety of the route. EDIT: Consequently, this retcon also means that Fate Shirou is aware that he has many circuits, but simply chose to not use them(?)。 |
GradationAirJun 12, 2015 11:35 PM
| Maybe he was aware but simply didn't know how to use them. Iirc there was something about him creating a new circuit every night he was training in the shed,instead of using his own existing ones.Or something. |
GradationAir said: MightyM16 said: I don't think that he "gave out " his circuit and is therefore unable to do magecraft anymore , I mean just after the event in the shack he traces his first sword He lost a few of his circuits he claimed that "he doesn't really use". From this, you can assume that Fate Shirou won't be able to have all 27 magic circuits functional ever in his life as opposed the other two (which actually have activated all 27 DURING the grail war). Fate Shirou barely used any of his magic circuits in the entirety of the route. EDIT: Consequently, this retcon also means that Fate Shirou is aware that he has many circuits, but simply chose to not use them(?)。 Wouldn't it mean though that he would become permanently unable to cast the RM, unless it would somehow be possible to restore the magic circuits? I mean he needs them all to cast it after all, or at least he seems to be using them all in UBW judging from the CG when he "speaks the true name". |
|
| He can still use it later in life. Also he can't cast UBW by himself even in the VN anyway. |
| mmmm let's see.....more badass Rin while fighting Berserker mmmm.... of course!! |
| I would watch it solely for Saber vs Rider and Saber vs Gilgamesh fight because honestly, it's the worst route there is and given ufotable's recent fuck ups, they'd probably make it worse than it already is unless they finally get their shit together and go back to their KnK/FZ era of adapting. |
 |
DrizzyXP said: lemme know if you still believe thisSure, it's the worst one imo, but still the one with the best romance and the one that portrays Saber the best. Fuck Fate Shirou though. |
| "I like young-girl sexual creations, Lolicon is just one hobby of my many hobbies," he says. I ask what his wife, standing nearby, thinks of his "hobby". "She probably thinks no problem," he replies. "Because she loves young boys sexually interacting with each other." |
Aure0lin said: DrizzyXP said: lemme know if you still believe thisSure, it's the worst one imo, but still the one with the best romance and the one that portrays Saber the best. Fuck Fate Shirou though. Yes. But "best romance" doesn't imply good :] |
| "I hate Shirou for being sexist but Saber romance is badly written cause she's not acting like a realistic girl" That's the Shirou-Saber haters self-contradictory excuse in a nutshell. Well no shit sherlock, living like that all her life she's not supposed to even know how to act like a woman. Impossible to take seriously. Keep jerking off to best waifus while ignoring what the story and the character developement is actually about. Shirou-Saber is what makes Fate/Stay night work in the first place. Rin is just a side character in UBW as well while Shirou basically spends all his life chasing after Artoria's legacy all the same, just staying empty in the end if they don't end up supporting each other. Sakura at least makes a real difference to Shirou's character in HF. Keep clinging to your excuses. |
FantyyyAug 29, 2020 3:48 PM
| Yep. I doubt it'll happen but I'll always want it |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) 2nd Season Episode 5 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Luna - Apr 25, 2015 |
1037 |
by Rain_Machika
»»
May 28, 10:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) 2nd Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Luna - Jun 20, 2015 |
1400 |
by sadoomi
»»
May 23, 7:46 PM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) 2nd Season Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Luna - Apr 11, 2015 |
1719 |
by icim_fitto
»»
Apr 27, 4:58 AM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) 2nd Season Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Luna - Apr 4, 2015 |
1557 |
by Swatheesh123
»»
Apr 9, 8:52 AM |
|
Poll: » Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works (TV) 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Luna - Jun 13, 2015 |
1574 |
by ToG25thBaam
»»
Mar 29, 12:29 PM |