| Is this serious? If it's a joke, I am NOT laughing. 0___0 |
| <!--link--><a href="http://myanimelist.net/animelist/angelfire892&sclick=1"> Being sane is over rated :) |
kimichan09 said: I think everyone finds it horrid because they don't like Disney You couldn't be more wrong. Everyone finds it horrid because this is the cancerous shit that's turning children into morons. |
  |
kimichan09 said: I think everyone finds it horrid because they don't like Disney DISNEY IS THE COOLEST THING SINCE AIR. But yes, Disney's animated stuff were some of the best films in creation, their live-action stuff however is lacking and seems to cater more to tween fads and "hormones" Let's just say that I had the same reaction to this as I did when I heard they were making a lilo and stitch anime. I shook my head and lost faith in the world, just a little bit more. |
| no matter how bad the manga is, it doesn't mean this isn't a fucking over-reaction. You ARE all over-reacting. Manga is not some sacred thing that is constantly perfect and amazing and can't be touched by crap. There is plenty of shitty manga, so why is this one so evil? Oh, right, because it's High School Musical. Similarly, High School Musical is not the worst film in the world. Yes, it is a bad film. It is filled with bad music, unrealistic portrayals of high school and teenagers, and cheese. But it is not the worst film in the world, jesus, it's not even the worst Disney Channel movie... I'm pretty disturbed that this is getting more negative attention than the Mein Kampf manga. That to me speaks volumes. :| But then of course, HSM is a cancer killing childhoods all over the world, so anyone who'd want to make a manga of it must be evil, right? Unlike someone who would want to make a manga of Mein Kampf. Naturally. :P also, stop being assholes to kimichan09 just because she likes HSM. She's made some good points. :/ |
| What crap is this? I never like HSM so I will never like itD: NEVER |
| I don't care how hard they try. It's not Manga. |
 Quidquid latine dictum sit, altum videtur. |
lizardcake said: ugh. do they realize that anime fans in general HATE things like High School Musical? I guess they didn't get the memo Way to be a tool. -eye roll- |
| I'm kinda torn. I give them props for attempting it. And after all, why the fuck shouldn't they? Someone else posting above me pointed out. Manga isn't a holy relic. It's paper with ink on it. Or in most peoples cases a computer screen with images and text. |
| When I was a kid, I thought that HSM was pretty good in the songs. Now... No... Just... no... |
| "I don't need a reason to save someone" Kamijou Touma |
| WTF is THIS i Say! |
| WTF? when did this BS came out? |
 Are you the bloody applause monkey? Keep your sh*t comments to yourself or go troll on 4chan. |
| Seriously, it's so wrong. O.O |
| My manga world isn't sacred anymoahr. And now seriously, I haven't watched that thing, nor do I plan to, but I'm still kinda against it. Cool, okay, let's have mangas with story by a non-japanese but... why this? There are so many talented fans out there, whose fanfiction I would be glad to see drawn and yet they make into manga this. Then again, I seriously don't care about High School Musical since I was intelligent enough to not watch it. It's not popular here anyway... I think o_O Well, Twillight is, and this makes me RAGE but oh, well. Stupid vampire fangirls /no offence/. I know quite a lot anime fangirls that love that thing. I don't flame them or anything but they can get quite annoying sometimes, talking about vampires non-stop. Still trying my best to be considerate though >< |
Nao-staniMay 29, 2010 8:07 PM
 |
| now this is messed up >_> and funny at the same time |
 |
Ontario said: I agreeMy fears have manifested themselves into manga form. |
|
| Why is every shit aspect of so called 'entertainment' infilltrating manga and anime? First Twilight, now this? Vile. |
| Dude my friend wanted to read it and when i look over it only 1 volume and 10 pages >_> MESSED UP |
|
| Oh god, this is just wrong TwT. |
| 1.Why are people posting about it if they don't like it 2.Don't read it,noone is forcing you to 3.HSM dosn't do well as a comic we all know this..lol The movie's are enjoyable which you can not get out of a drawing.An animation would of been move precise seeing as there would be audio and movement which is what the whole HSM franchise is all about. |
 |
| WHY DOES THIS EXIST? Just...WHY??? The art looks nice, I'll give it that, but...I believe a massive facepalm is in order. Gentlemen! (and ladies) |
 |
Osianilist said: The movie's are enjoyable which you can not get out of a drawing.An animation would of been move precise seeing as there would be audio and movement which is what the whole HSM franchise is all about. Y-you enjoyed them? Thats probably why you can't understand the typical reaction. Majority of people here probably can't stand HSM. |
| Just sad, deeply sad. Why must they litter such garbage in the manga/anime world. |
 Where there is no imagination there is no horror. || Arthur Conan Doyle || Happy Halloween! |
| lol seriously? :'D Just one chapter scanlated huh? Wasn't as bad as I expected from the comments though. Kind of curious to read the rest ;c |
| really???... saw this on mangafox the other day :/ |
| You're shitting me, right? |
| HAHAHA, wai-what? No. Hellbatshit, no. MUST. NOT. ALLOW,,,My sister to see THIS. She could get the impression that THIS is the manga i read. I would shelter myself in a narrow space, for the rest of my life. |
| I promise to kill myself if I ever read that shit !!!! |
Penko said: Osianilist said: The movie's are enjoyable which you can not get out of a drawing.An animation would of been move precise seeing as there would be audio and movement which is what the whole HSM franchise is all about. Y-you enjoyed them? Thats probably why you can't understand the typical reaction. Majority of people here probably can't stand HSM. I actually like the movies like Osianilist. I love how many people I know freak out just cause I actually like watching it. I knew that had an on stage play in Japan for High School Musical and Nami Tamaki sang a song for the second part of HS, but a manga? LOL! Really? I'm amused. Japan is being Japan. *dies hard of laughter* |
JunjunKiJan 22, 2011 5:29 PM
    |
| 2 years passed and I'm still laughing at posts on first page. XD |
| How many chapters does this have? |
| Good pacing. xD |
| I definitely have superpowers. I can feel it in my balls. |
| too bad there's something worse than the patheticness of this manga manga,everyone who posted n this thread lol. |
| lol @ img bbcode not working, mal is such a great site |
| When are more chapters coming out..? ;^; |
| they dont have an eyepatch?? |
| Score : 3.08 ... Lowest I've seen on MAL -.- |
| Honobono Log - best slice of life short -------------------------------------------- most kawaii loli overlord ---------------------------- Donquixote Doflamingo AMV - Control |
| Why the hell would they make this into manga? It's stupid! |
  |
| Wait, people are actually still reading this? |
| Wait what ? never heard of this ._. |
 |
| 1/10 |
Liquidize said: Siing said: At least there's no sound if one chooses to read this.. You're right, but some people actually put this on their list. :/ Like me, because I have to set my standard of 1/10. It reminds me (and should also remind other people) to not give a manga that is pretty bad 1/10, ever, since there will always be HSM. |
| My Reviews and Rants: http://bunny1ov3r.wordpress.com/ 痛就是爱 |
| Disney, why would you maim the beauty of my tween days with this manga? I mean. yeah, the real High School Musical was crap, but at least it was kinda entertaining as a kid. Reading this just pains me on a physical level. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » High School Musical Chapter 1 DiscussionHatchetGirl - Dec 9, 2011 |
28 |
by Ratris_Decision
»»
Apr 2, 12:56 AM |
|
» Worst Manga Ever?ExTemplar - Apr 26, 2015 |
8 |
by hexigoon
»»
Feb 28, 3:21 AM |