| I had to recheck the source and lol they went Hi-Ho Tinfoil Away! on this adaptation lmao.... |
| I don't think it's that bad. I mean, they had to rewrite some stuff so it would fit 10 episodes. We have to agree there's no much content since the chapters did stop coming, so, they had to do that. It's not that bad, as I said. I've seen worse adapted titles. |
DoctaLinker |
Vacation said: No, it completely throws out key plot points, and makes it such that if it tries to get on track, it's generated plot holes.I don't think it's that bad. I mean, they had to rewrite some stuff so it would fit 10 episodes. We have to agree there's no much content since the chapters did stop coming, so, they had to do that. It's not that bad, as I said. I've seen worse adapted titles. While it's possible for it to get on track as an adaptation, the entire first episode is basically wasted on that front, so episode two would be the first one adapting anything significant from the manga - that's 10% of the series devoted to boldly going nowhere. Otherwise, it's going to continue to be mostly anime original. It's not like there aren't convenient places to stop for a relatively short adaptation either, so that's not the issue. So, this has nothing to do with the time limit - it's all about tossing out the manga. |
japzone said: My thoughts as well. It's practically not an adaptation anymore with only the characters being the same. None of the content from Volume 1 actually made it to this episode. It's crazy how they were able to make the generic ecchi manga into something much worse.I'm stunned with how badly this has been adapted. Sure the manga isn't anything amazing, but if the Manga was Earth, than this Anime is hell. I've seen some pretty bad adaptations but this is ranking pretty high on my list. Any other Manga readers disappointed by this adaptation? |
| The title got me looolll Pray for mangaka |
 |
revx said: Wow, I think I might start reading the manga just to see how it compares. Yeah, just what I was thinking. |
| I haven't seen the anime adaptation yet but one thing I disliked a lot in the manga is the harem setting, things could be smoother and have some substance. |
| I love this anime and yes... the mangaka is probly crying tears of happiness because his work got picked up by an animation studio and it even got animated. Thats the best thing anyone can ask for as a mangaka. |
FlamingMangos said: I love this anime and yes... the mangaka is probly crying tears of happiness because his work got picked up by an animation studio and it even got animated. Thats the best thing anyone can ask for as a mangaka. With some exceptions, this. Anyway, why is it that people demand that an anime follows the source closely? I don't mind if they deviated from it slightly, or make an entirely different show from it, as long as it's entertaining, and right now, I'm still liking this show quite a bit. If I want to know what the story of the manga is, I'll go read the manga, as that is the only way I'll get the full grasp of the story, especially when this show only has 10 episodes and most likely won't be a huge seller to merit more anime to flesh out the story more. Heck, maybe that is why the anime is the way it is now. It's probably lose-lose either way you look at it. Besides, the anime is made to tell people that there's a manga out there, so if it will make more people buy it, than the show will have served its purpose. |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
FlamingMangos said: I love this anime and yes... the mangaka is probly crying tears of happiness because his work got picked up by an animation studio and it even got animated. Thats the best thing anyone can ask for as a mangaka. If the animation studio was ARMS hmmm maybe the mangaka was really going to cry literally. |
 |
AO968 said: Anyway, why is it that people demand that an anime follows the source closely? I don't mind if they deviated from it slightly, or make an entirely different show from it, as long as it's entertaining, and right now, I'm still liking this show quite a bit. Agreed, I've read the manga, and i'm watching the show, and they are indeed quite different. But so what? The manga wasn't the best thing out there to begin with, and neither is this show, but I find them enjoyable anyway. As far as i'm concerned, as far as certain scenes (such as Shinichirou's boobie back wash) make it into the adaptation, I'm happy. :P |
| I seriauosly don't understand why it's rated so low and you are hating. There are many much worse series that are rated higher. From 3 eps I saw it's strong 7 from me. Or I just have shit taste? |
| Actually the Anime was better than the manga because Arms Studio (Known for Elfen Lied, Gokukoku no Brynhildr) was changing extreme Ecchi scenes to Gore (which I liked about this). |
| Haters always gonna hate. |
| The manga is nothing to sneeze at. The anime is good, definitely like it more than the manga. Ukatoid said: I seriauosly don't understand why it's rated so low and you are hating. There are many much worse series that are rated higher. From 3 eps I saw it's strong 7 from me. Or I just have shit taste? No, you just have common sense. Whoever's excepting super plot and animation is borderline retarded. |
 |
| Latest episode has the samurai golems controlled by the blonde enemy mage rather than by their original controller. It doesn't surprise me much since we've already seen so many changes (and so much important plot and character development skipped over). When the thunder beast showed up as a random monster without any plot relevance in episode 1 this show had already indicated how badly they would mangle the adaptation. My guess is that the mangaka has little or no input on this adaptation. |
Please don't feed the trolls! In my next life I want to collide at the corner with the cute transfer student carrying a piece of toast in her mouth...rodac |
| An adaptation is better than nothing at all. Imagine all the artists that put a lifetime worth of ideas and stories into their works and end up getting cancelled after a dozen chapters or not serialized at all. |
 |
rodac said: Latest episode has the samurai golems controlled by the blonde enemy mage rather than by their original controller. It doesn't surprise me much since we've already seen so many changes (and so much important plot and character development skipped over). When the thunder beast showed up as a random monster without any plot relevance in episode 1 this show had already indicated how badly they would mangle the adaptation. My guess is that the mangaka has little or no input on this adaptation. Yeah this adaption was a horrible mess. I don't care about the first episode having the Raiju in the beginning. But on the 4th episode having Suseri transferred to Sakuya's school just as if it's normal it became terrible. Suseri doesn't go to school because her family forbids it. So Nadeshiko just teach her at home (home schooling). And because she doesn't go to a regular school she can't make friends other than her relatives or subordinates. And the Samurai Spirit being (Yashaou) controlled by Isuca was supposed to be planned by Nadeshiko to test Shinichirou. |
| Haters always gonna hate. |
| the show is not completely ignoring the manga, it just rearranging the chapter.....................alot and making alteration and focuses too much on the Ecchi, which is very little in the manga. The person who said Sasuri doesn't go to school read the end of chapter 24. |
| I don't know if the author is crying, but I sure as hell am. WTF IS THIS SHIT?!!! WHY?! Can't this goddamn studio make ONE good adaptation? They already butchered Brynhindlr, they had to butcher this one as well? |
 |
komic said: the show is not completely ignoring the manga, it just rearranging the chapter.....................alot and making alteration and focuses too much on the Ecchi, which is very little in the manga. The person who said Sasuri doesn't go to school read the end of chapter 24. It's the opposite. Are you really reading the manga? The manga focuses on too much Ecchi but the anime focuses on gore. And just to be clear. I didn't say Suseri doesn't ever go to school. I just meant to say they didn't bother to make the back story of Suseri not being able to attend on regular school. DmonHiro said: I don't know if the author is crying, but I sure as hell am. WTF IS THIS SHIT?!!! WHY?! Can't this goddamn studio make ONE good adaptation? They already butchered Brynhindlr, they had to butcher this one as well? Then always keep in mind, Arms Studio = Fucked Up (So Bad) Adaptation. |
| Haters always gonna hate. |
| Shit anime, dropped on minute 4:18 on episode 2. Too shitty to handle. |
 |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Isuca Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 27, 2015 |
91 |
by gannoncannon55
»»
Apr 21, 8:49 PM |
|
Poll: » Isuca Episode 9 DiscussionStark700 - Mar 20, 2015 |
37 |
by gannoncannon55
»»
Apr 21, 7:50 PM |
|
Poll: » Isuca Episode 8 DiscussionStark700 - Mar 13, 2015 |
34 |
by gannoncannon55
»»
Apr 19, 7:25 PM |
|
Poll: » Isuca Episode 7 DiscussionStark700 - Mar 6, 2015 |
46 |
by gannoncannon55
»»
Apr 18, 6:39 PM |
|
Poll: » Isuca Episode 6 DiscussionStark700 - Feb 27, 2015 |
42 |
by gannoncannon55
»»
Apr 17, 7:00 PM |